Paychex, Inc. (NASDAQ:PAYX) and Automatic Data Processing, Inc. (NASDAQ:ADP) have surged by 18.43% and 38.21%, respectively, over the last six months, compared to a gain of over 42% by the Insider Monkey Billionaire Index.
Payroll looks like a boring business. But that may actually be one of its biggest advantages.
Companies can switch accounting software. They can change marketing tools. They can probably replace a CRM. But payroll is different. When a company changes payroll providers, it is not just changing software. It is moving employee data, tax information, benefits, and other processes that need to work correctly every single pay period.
That makes payroll much stickier than it appears.
The moat is not really payroll
Paychex, Inc. and Automatic Data Processing, Inc. both started with payroll, but neither company is trying to remain just a payroll processor.
The bigger opportunity is to become the system that a business relies on to manage its workforce. Payroll can be the way in. From there, the company can sell benefits, retirement plans, HR services, insurance, and other products. The more of those services a customer uses, the harder it becomes to replace the provider.
This is where Paychex is becoming more interesting.
The company is pushing what it calls a One Paychex strategy, where its sales and customer-success teams are encouraged to sell the full range of products instead of treating payroll, HR, and advisory services as separate businesses. Management said this approach was producing more internal referrals into higher-value services, while an ASO customer moving into PEO can generate roughly 3.5 times the revenue.
That is more important than another new payroll feature.
Paychex is effectively trying to get more valuable as the customer gets deeper into the platform.
On June 30, we published an article about the Nasdaq stocks to buy for retirement. PAYX ranked eighth on that list. The #1 stock on that list returned 15% since the article was published.
Paycor gives Paychex something it was missing
Paycor gave Paychex, Inc. a much stronger position among midsize businesses and brought another 2.5 million employees onto the platform for potential cross-selling. Paychex has already started pushing products such as Perks into that employee base, while its advisory businesses are also gaining traction with larger customers.
That said, acquisitions do not automatically create a better business. However, there is a reason this one could matter beyond simply adding revenue. Paychex now has a larger customer base to sell its broader range of services into. In other words, the acquisition potentially increases the value of the existing moat rather than just making the company bigger.
Automatic Data Processing, Inc. starts with a similar advantage, only on a much larger scale.
It serves more than 1.1 million clients across more than 140 countries. That matters because payroll becomes much harder when a company has employees spread across different states and countries, each with their own regulations and reporting requirements. ADP has spent decades building infrastructure around that complexity.
DON’T MISS: 10 Best Beverage Stocks to Buy According to Analysts
AI could make the moat stronger
AI should make basic payroll software easier to build. That sounds bad for Paychex and ADP.
But it may actually make their broader businesses more valuable.
Paychex has more than 50 trillion proprietary workforce data points across payroll, HR, and benefits. It is using that data to build WISE, its AI platform, into the actual workflows where payroll and HR decisions are made. The company has also deployed more than 2,000 AI agents and features across the business.
ADP is taking the same approach. Its AI tools are being embedded into payroll, benefits, HR, and compliance, while its workforce data gives the company visibility into how employment patterns and wages are changing.
But ADP still has the stronger moat
ADP’s global scale is difficult to reproduce, and its customer base stretches from small businesses to large multinational companies. It also has a bigger international opportunity and a more established position in enterprise payroll.
Paychex, though, has a different path to strengthening its position. It does not need to beat ADP globally. It needs to become more valuable to the businesses it already serves. If it can move customers from payroll into PEO, benefits, retirement, and other advisory services, the economics of each customer improve even without dramatic growth in the payroll market.
There is a genuine bear case here. The HR software market is crowded, and companies such as Workday, UKG, and others can attack individual pieces of the workforce stack. AI could also reduce the importance of traditional software interfaces. And Paychex still has to prove that Paycor will produce the cross-selling and growth benefits it expects.
The Valuation Gap Is Interesting
Paychex trades at 17.54x forward earnings, compared with 22.03x for ADP. Their trailing P/Es are 20.73x and 24.65x, respectively. The bigger gap between trailing and forward P/E suggests analysts expect a stronger earnings recovery at Paychex. That could work in its favor, but the company still needs to deliver on those expectations.
ADP deserves a premium. It serves more than 1.1 million clients across over 140 countries and has a stronger position among large businesses with complicated payroll requirements. Its scale and global infrastructure make it difficult to displace. Investors are paying for an established business with a more proven ability to handle that complexity.
Paychex is cheaper partly because it still has something to prove. The Paycor acquisition gives it access to more midsize businesses, while the One Paychex strategy is designed to sell more services to existing customers. But Paychex needs to show that these initiatives can generate stronger earnings growth, rather than simply add customers and products.
The interesting part is that Paychex does not need to match ADP’s global reach to justify a higher valuation. If it can get more customers to use its HR, benefits, retirement, and advisory services, it can increase revenue from its existing customer base. That could make the business more valuable without requiring particularly strong growth in the payroll market itself.
Conclusion
ADP has the stronger moat today, mainly because its scale and global infrastructure are difficult to replicate. But Paychex may have the more interesting improvement story.
The company is trying to make payroll the beginning of the customer relationship rather than the end of it. If that works, Paychex could become a much more valuable business without needing the payroll market itself to grow particularly fast.
At 17.54x forward earnings, that possibility is not fully reflected in the valuation.
Market Sentiment
Hedge fund sentiment toward Paychex was mixed in the second quarter. According to Insider Monkey’s database, 40 hedge funds held Paychex in Q2, down from 43 funds in Q1, while the value of their positions increased from $949.0 million to $1.23 billion.
Hedge fund sentiment toward ADP weakened in the second quarter. The number of hedge funds holding ADP fell from 67 in Q1 to 61 in Q2, while the value of their positions declined from $2.89 billion to $2.62 billion.
READ NEXT: Visa vs. Mastercard: Does a 241% Return on Equity Make Mastercard the Better Buy? and Boeing (BA) Has Negative EBITDA and Positive Net Income. Which One Is Real?
This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
