Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. (NASDAQ:WBD) shareholders just got one of the biggest pieces of good news since Paramount Skydance (NASDAQ:PSKY) agreed to buy the company. But good news for existing shareholders doesn’t necessarily make WBD an equally attractive stock for someone buying today.
DON’T MISS: Disney Adds Formula E to Disney+: Can Live Sports Strengthen its Streaming Business?
Paramount has settled the legal challenges brought by California and 11 other states and the Writers Guild of America, removing major obstacles to its $110 billion acquisition of WBD. The development sent WBD shares up more than 10% on September 21, according to Reuters. The deal now looks considerably closer to the finish line. The question for investors is how much of that improving outlook is already reflected in WBD shares.
Bull Case
The strongest part of the WBD investment case is that a major source of uncertainty around the Paramount transaction has been removed. California and 11 other states sued in July to block the acquisition, arguing that combining the two media companies would reduce competition and create a giant with the power to raise prices. The Writers Guild separately challenged the deal, arguing that it would hurt writers’ pay and working conditions.
Both disputes have now been settled, as the state agreement comes with significant conditions. Paramount committed to spending at least $300 million more each year on domestic film production compared with 2025 levels. It also agreed to produce 30 theatrical films annually during each of the first two years covered by the settlement and 32 annually during each of the following three years.
READ ALSO: Can Eli Lilly Catch Novo Nordisk in the Oral GLP-1 Race?
At least four films each year must be independent productions and at least 20% must be blockbusters. Paramount could face a $30 million payment for each film it falls short of the required annual output. The company also agreed not to raise rates on theater operators for three years and will establish an editorial independence board for CNN and CBS. Those concessions allowed Paramount to avoid an immediate forced sale of cable assets such as CNN or its film franchises.
Bear Case
Although the legal picture has improved, that doesn’t automatically mean WBD is an attractive stock to buy after the settlement-driven rally. WBD shares surged more than 10% after the agreements were announced, according to Reuters at the time of its reporting. That matters because this is increasingly a merger-arbitrage investment rather than a conventional bet on the future earnings of Warner Bros. Discovery.
A new investor’s potential return depends heavily on the difference between the price paid for WBD shares and the $31 cash consideration ultimately received if the transaction closes. Reuters estimates that the amount to be roughly $7 million per day that Paramount would owe WBD shareholders after September 30, and resolving the lawsuits therefore removes a potential source of costly delay for Paramount.
But the ticking clock doesn’t eliminate merger risk. Until the acquisition actually closes, WBD shareholders are still waiting for the transaction to be completed. The economics after closing are also primarily Paramount’s problem rather than WBD shareholders’. The companies previously said the combination is expected to generate more than $6 billion in synergies, while Reuters reported that the combined company is expected to carry $80 billion in debt. Those figures underline the scale of the transaction, but WBD shareholders are being bought out for cash rather than receiving shares in the combined company.
Conclusion
The case for WBD has changed. When the California-led coalition and the Writers Guild were trying to stop the transaction, the central risk was whether Paramount could get its $110 billion acquisition through the legal challenges. The September 21 settlements substantially reduced that particular uncertainty, while regulators in jurisdictions including the European Union and Britain had already cleared the deal. That’s clearly positive for WBD shareholders waiting for their cash consideration.
For someone considering buying WBD after the settlement-driven rally, however, the calculation is less obvious. The relevant question is no longer whether Warner Bros. Discovery can grow HBO, streaming, or its movie franchises over the next several years. It is how much return remains between the price an investor pays for WBD and the cash consideration, plus any applicable ticking consideration, relative to the remaining time and risk before closing.
That makes WBD a much clearer deal-completion trade than a traditional media investment. The legal outlook has improved substantially, but whether the stock is still worth buying depends on whether the remaining spread adequately compensates investors for waiting until Paramount actually closes the acquisition.
READ NEXT: Can Eli Lilly Catch Novo Nordisk in the Oral GLP-1 Race? AND Abbott vs. Intuitive Surgical: Is Consistent Growth Better Than Premium Growth?
This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
