Western Digital Corporation (NASDAQ:WDC) closed at $397.28 on October 9. The stock has returned 13.4% during the last six months, compared to a 24.3% return for the Insider Monkey Billionaire Index and 15.1% for State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust.
Western Digital reports a net margin no hardware manufacturer has ever sustained. Storage has a long history of destroying anyone who mistakes a shortage for a moat. This is a shortage.
READ ALSO: 10 Best Undervalued Stocks to Buy in October
The Profit Came From a Shareholding, Not From Drives:
No storage company keeps nearly three-quarters of its revenue as profit, and this one did not either. Western Digital separated its flash memory business as SanDisk in February 2025 and retained a stake. Accounting rules require that retained interest be marked to market, and SanDisk shares rose a long way. The resulting gain is most of the reported profit.
The cash statement confirms it plainly. Free cash flow came in at a fraction of reported net income, and that spread is the shareholding rather than the drives. Strip it out and what remains is genuinely strong, because the operating margin of 43.61% belongs to Western Digital and it is a remarkable number for storage hardware. Revenue grew 43.80% as data centres bought high-capacity drives faster than the industry could build them, on a balance sheet carrying barely a billion of debt. The stake itself is in a chip business, which is the sector doing the work here and the reason so much money sits in the semiconductors billionaires added to this year. Their most-held name is up 18% since June.
DON’T MISS: 10 Best Stocks to Buy for High Returns in 2026
This Is What a Cycle Top Looks Like:
Storage is cyclical, and this is what the top of a cycle looks like. Drive prices rose because buyers wanted capacity faster than it could be manufactured, not because Western Digital won share.
That matters for how the multiple should be read. A cyclical trades at its lowest earnings multiple precisely when its earnings are highest, which is the opposite of a bargain signal. Micron spent years looking cheap on exactly this arithmetic and expensive once memory pricing turned.
Capacity is already being added across the industry, which is the predictable response to margins like these. The question is not whether supply arrives but when. Cheapest multiple at the highest earnings is the oldest trap in commodities, and avoiding it is most of what separates a cyclical from the high return list we published in January. The one we ranked first there is up 24% since.
The shares rose over six months without keeping pace with the market, and they still sit far below their 52-week high, which gives some sense of how violent the swings here are.
The Valuation Case:
On earnings, the stock trades at 12.40 times forward, on analyst consensus estimates, and that figure is not a bargain signal for the reasons above. The price-to-book of 18.99 is the measure that does not flatter the company, and it is the one that survives a pricing reversal. You are paying nineteen times the stated value of the assets for a manufacturer at a cyclical peak.
The verdict is that Western Digital looks cheap on peak earnings and expensive on assets, which is the classic profile of a cyclical at the top. Both things are true, and only one of them persists through a downturn. The operating business deserves credit, and the price does not reflect a permanent rerating. Profit that does not depend on a shortage is a different kind of cheap altogether, and that is what the profitable stocks we judged most underpriced are built on. Their leader has returned 16% since.
Conclusion:
Two businesses are buried in this income statement, and only one of them makes drives. The one that does grew revenue sharply at an exceptional operating margin, on a balance sheet carrying almost no debt. However, the net margin comes mostly from marking a retained SanDisk shareholding, and free cash flow arrived well below reported net income. The forward multiple is what a storage company looks like at the top of a pricing cycle rather than what a cheap one looks like. Everything comes back to price-to-book, the one figure that does not fall away when drive prices do.
Market Sentiment:
Western Digital Corporation was held by 98 hedge funds with a combined stake value of about $9.94 billion at the end of Q2 2026 in the Insider Monkey database. This is up from 83 hedge fund holders with a cumulative investment value of around $6.57 billion in the previous quarter.
READ NEXT: 10 Best Stocks to Buy for High Returns in 2026 and 10 Best Semiconductor Stocks to Buy According to Billionaires
This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
