During the October 5 episode of Mad Money, a caller asked about FirstCash Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:FCFS), pointing to its valuation and pawn operations across the United States, Latin America, and the United Kingdom. Jim Cramer declined to make a recommendation, as he said:
You know, I have looked at it… One time, I did recommend it a long, long time ago, but because it’s a pawn shop company, I don’t understand that business model well enough to be able to opine on it, and I think therefore, it’s too tricky for me.
The business model that kept Cramer on the sidelines was central to an earlier bullish case for FirstCash, which viewed tighter credit conditions as a potential advantage for the company.
Pawn Lending Growth Extends Beyond Acquisitions
FirstCash Holdings, Inc. provides small, nonrecourse loans secured by personal property and sells merchandise through its pawn stores. The collateral-based model differs from conventional unsecured consumer lending.
The company reported second-quarter revenue of approximately $1.07 billion, up 29.4%, while net income increased 56% to approximately $93.5 million. Adjusted earnings per share rose 40%. Same-store pawn receivables increased 22%, showing that growth was not solely the result of adding acquired locations. Higher receivables can support future pawn service charges, although the ultimate return also depends on how well the company values collateral and sells merchandise when customers do not redeem it.
Consumer Finance Adds Risks Beyond Pawn Shops
FirstCash Holdings, Inc.’s American First Finance operation creates a separate exposure to consumer payment performance. AFF’s second-quarter pretax operating profit was approximately $29 million and declined year-over-year, partly highlighting retail-partner bankruptcies. Delinquencies in its lease portfolio increased to 25.6% from 23.2%. Those developments matter because investors cannot assess the entire company solely through its pawn lending model. AFF’s results can weaken even when pawn demand remains strong.
The stock also traded at approximately 17.5x forward earnings, compared with 14.6x for pawn-store competitor EZCORP. That premium means FirstCash is not the cheaper choice within this narrow peer comparison, despite the modest-looking multiple mentioned by the caller. Continued growth must justify paying more for its earnings.
Fund Ownership Rises Along With Meaningful Short Positions
According to Insider Monkey’s database tracking over 1000 elite hedge funds, 35 hedge funds owned FirstCash Holdings, Inc. in the second quarter, compared with 31 in the first. Among those funds, Hood River Capital Management had the most significant position in the stock with around 1.2 million shares. Short interest was 6.50% of the float. Fund counts alone do not establish how strongly investors are positioned in either direction.
Cramer’s reluctance reflects the limits of his familiarity with the business, rather than a specific criticism of the latest results. FirstCash is producing strong pawn growth, but its consumer-finance exposure and premium to EZCORP deserve attention. Understanding those differences is more useful than relying on the P/E alone.
READ NEXT: Jim Cramer Says This Company Faces a Test With Little Room for Error and Delta’s (DAL) Amazon Decision Sends Jim Cramer’s Attention Back to SpaceX (SPCX).
