Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) shares climbed 12.6% to $178.09 on August 14 after S&P Dow Jones Indices said the social-media company would join the S&P 500 before trading begins on August 18.
J.P. Morgan estimates that index-tracking funds will require exposure equivalent to about 16.7 million Reddit shares, equivalent to nearly three times Reddit’s average daily trading volume of 5.98 million shares since its March 2024 IPO. For Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT), that creates a measurable near-term catalyst.
It does not automatically change the operating outlook. Before the rally, the stock was down more than 31% in 2026 and more than 42% below its September 2025 intraday high, reflecting concerns about search traffic and user growth.
brett-jordan-0FytazjHhxs-unsplash
BULL CASE: INDEX MEMBERSHIP BROADENS THE BUYER BASE
The strongest argument for Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) is that the demand is not theoretical. Passive funds must align their portfolios with the index, while benchmark-aware active managers may also increase exposure.
That could deepen liquidity and expand institutional ownership. Inclusion also raises Reddit’s visibility and relevance among large benchmark-focused investors that may have been less likely to own a younger public company outside major indexes.
The operating business gives Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) support beyond the index catalyst. Second-quarter revenue increased 61% to $805 million, beating the $730.4 million consensus, while advertiser count rose more than 70%.
Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) also forecast third-quarter revenue of $860 million to $870 million, above the $829.1 million analyst estimate. Adjusted EBITDA guidance of $385 million to $395 million exceeded the $369 million consensus.
Those figures matter because forced buying is more likely to hold when it attracts investors to a business already exceeding expectations. Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) is not relying on index inclusion to offset declining revenue or weak guidance.
BEAR CASE: FORCED BUYING HAS AN EXPIRATION DATE
The problem is that the estimated 16.7 million-share requirement is primarily a rebalancing event. Once index funds complete their purchases, Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) will need other buyers to maintain the higher price.
According to Stephens analyst Melissa Roberts, new S&P 500 members have historically outperformed from announcement through inclusion, with the largest gain occurring immediately after the announcement. Stephens’ analysis found that new members historically lagged the index by about 2% during the three months following inclusion.
Reddit also has an unresolved traffic issue. U.S. daily active unique visitors increased 6% in the second quarter, down from 7% in the preceding quarter, as changes in search algorithms made referrals choppier.
Rest-of-World daily active unique visitors rose 28%, but their average revenue per user was $2.26, compared with $11.85 in the United States. Strong international user growth therefore does not fully offset slower expansion in Reddit’s most valuable market.
Index membership does not reduce Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT)’s dependence on search engines, accelerate the conversion of search-driven visitors into direct or app users, or improve advertising economics by itself. It changes demand for the shares, not demand for the product.
INSIDER MONKEY’S HEDGE FUND DATA
The available filings reflect positions held before the S&P 500 announcement. According to Insider Monkey’s latest quarterly data, 70 hedge funds held Reddit, Inc. (NYSE:RDDT) at the end of the first quarter of 2026, down from 82 funds three months earlier.
WILL INDEX DEMAND HOLD THE GAIN?
That estimated demand could support Reddit into the August 17 closing rebalance, although part of the price impact may already have been reflected in the announcement-day rally.
The durability of the gain is a different question. Revenue, advertiser growth, and guidance remain strong, but search volatility continues to constrain U.S. user growth. Holding the rally will depend on whether Reddit attracts enough long-term buyers after the index-related demand has been absorbed.
While we acknowledge the risk and potential of RDDT as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and doing so within a shorter time frame. If you are looking for an AI stock that is more promising than RDDT and that has 10,000% upside potential, check out our report about this cheapest AI stock.
READ NEXT: ConocoPhillips (COP): Wall Street Sees More Upside Despite Leadership Shakeup and Here is Why Chevron (CVX) is a Favorite Among Hedge Funds
Disclosure: None. This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
Hedge Fund Resource Center