The licensing practices of Oracle Corporation (NYSE:ORCL) are on the radar of European Union antitrust regulators, a person familiar with the matter told Reuters on September 1, in a case similar to one involving German rival SAP SE (NYSE:SAP) that was settled with concessions in July.
The European Commission, the EU’s competition enforcer, is seeking information from third parties on the issue, which could either help build a case or lead regulators to drop it if no evidence of wrongdoing turns up. Oracle did not immediately respond to a request for comment. A commission spokesperson said the EU “will continue to monitor possible further anticompetitive practices and abusive conduct in this sector” but confirmed there is no formal investigation into any company at this stage. In July, SAP agreed to make it easier for customers to switch to rival service providers or end their contracts, averting a potential fine that could have reached 10% of its global annual revenue.
Bull Case
SAP SE (NYSE:SAP) resolved the EU licensing dispute through commercial concessions rather than a fine. The company offered to make it easier for customers to switch to rival service providers or terminate contracts, avoiding a potential penalty of up to 10% of global annual revenue. That outcome suggests SAP can address regulatory concerns without taking a direct financial hit.
The SAP SE precedent offers Oracle Corporation (NYSE:ORCL) a manageable potential outcome. Regulators reached voluntary commercial concessions with SAP rather than imposing a fine. If Oracle faces a similar process, it could potentially address regulators’ concerns through changes to licensing and switching terms rather than absorb a punitive financial penalty.
Oracle’s overall business is growing rapidly since remaining performance obligations reached $638 billion, while fiscal 2027 guidance calls for total revenue growth of 27% to 29%. Cloud revenue growth of 58% to 64%. Management also reaffirmed its target for 31% compound annual revenue growth through fiscal 2030, which could make the licensing scrutiny relatively small compared with Oracle’s growth.
Oracle’s current growth engine centers on cloud and AI rather than traditional on-premises licensing. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure and AI contracts with customers such as OpenAI, xAI, Meta, Nvidia and AMD now drive much of the company’s momentum, while those businesses rely more heavily on cloud consumption than the traditional licensing terms under scrutiny.
Bear Case
SAP SE (NYSE:SAP)’s concessions could weaken an important part of its business model. Making it easier for customers to switch providers or terminate contracts could reduce customer lock-in and switching costs. It potentially weakens SAP’s pricing power and recurring revenue over time.
Even without a fine, the SAP outcome creates a risk for Oracle Corporation (NYSE:ORCL). EU regulators could force Oracle to make similar concessions on customer lock-in and license portability. Those mandatory changes would weaken the pricing power and high switching costs that traditional software vendors rely on for steady revenue.
The scrutiny arrives as Oracle faces heavy funding demands for its AI expansion. The company expects up to $95 billion in fiscal 2027 capital expenditures and plans to raise $40 billion through additional debt and equity to fund its AI buildout. With free cash flow already negative, extra compliance costs could add pressure to an already capital-intensive growth strategy.
Oracle also faces margin pressure from its AI expansion before any antitrust costs emerge. Management expects gross margins to decline in fiscal 2027 as new data center capacity ramps toward full utilization. This creates another source of cost pressure as Oracle expands its infrastructure.
EU scrutiny of major technology companies could create a prolonged regulatory risk for Oracle if the Commission eventually opens a formal case. Microsoft, Google and SAP SE have all faced EU scrutiny over technology practices. So Oracle could face years of regulatory attention and compliance costs if regulators escalate the matter.
Hedge Fund Data
Insider Monkey’s database shows Oracle Corporation (NYSE:ORCL) was held by 119 hedge funds in the second quarter of 2026, up from 115 in the first quarter. SAP SE, the direct precedent in this case, was held by 35 funds, up slightly from 33. Oracle draws more than three times SAP’s hedge fund count.
Conclusion
SAP’s EU licensing dispute shows how regulators can challenge software companies’ customer lock-in practices. Oracle’s cloud and AI growth gives it significant momentum. However, regulatory concessions could weaken pricing power and switching costs. Oracle also faces heavy infrastructure spending and margin pressure.
Investors should watch how both companies balance growth with the financial and regulatory risks surrounding their licensing models.
READ NEXT: Meta’s $18 Billion Teen Safety Deal Puts the Pressure on TikTok and YouTube Next and Tesla (TSLA) Rolls Out its Safety Numbers ahead of a Make-or-Break EU Vote.
