Shopify Inc. (NASDAQ:SHOP) and MercadoLibre, Inc. (NASDAQ:MELI) are both among the strongest growth stories in e-commerce, but investors are paying very different prices for them. Shopify trades at 58.82x forward earnings, compared with 32.79x for MercadoLibre.
That is a big difference. Shopify is trading at roughly 1.8 times MercadoLibre’s forward earnings multiple. The obvious question is whether Shopify’s business is good enough to deserve that premium.
In mid-June, we published an article about 12 best tech stocks to invest in on the dip. Shopify ranked fifth on that list. The #1 stock in that list returned more than 30% since the article was published.
Why Shopify’s model stands out
Shopify Inc. generated $3.6 billion of revenue in the second quarter, up 34%, while gross merchandise volume, or GMV, the value of transactions processed through its platform, increased 32% to $116 billion. It also produced an 18% free cash flow margin. More importantly, this growth is broad. Shopify is gaining business across merchant sizes, geographies, and channels.
What I like about Shopify is the way the business grows with its merchants.
A small business can start on Shopify and eventually move into higher-priced plans, payments, point-of-sale, business-to-business tools and other services as it gets larger. Shopify said merchants reaching $1 million in annual GMV had a 92% retention rate, while that figure rose to 97% for merchants above $10 million.
DON’T MISS: 10 Cheap Stocks That Will Go to the Moon According to Reddit
AI could strengthen Shopify
AI could make this model even more interesting. Shopify has been preparing its product catalog and checkout infrastructure for AI-powered shopping, where software agents can discover products and even complete purchases. AI-driven traffic and orders tripled year over year in Q2.
The attraction here is that Shopify does not need to become the destination where consumers shop. It can simply remain the infrastructure underneath those transactions. That could matter if online commerce becomes more fragmented across search engines, social platforms, chatbots, and AI assistants.
But MercadoLibre has built something that is arguably harder to compete with.
MercadoLibre’s ecosystem is the real moat
It is not just an e-commerce marketplace. It combines the marketplace with Mercado Pago, its digital payments and financial-services business, and logistics. The interaction between these businesses is the important part. Someone who shops on MercadoLibre can use Mercado Pago, receive credit, keep money in the ecosystem, and then return to the marketplace to spend it.
Management said ecosystemic users, those who use both commerce and fintech, generate much higher engagement and profitability than users who use only one side. These users grew 37% year over year in Q2.
MercadoLibre’s revenue surpassed $10 billion for the first time, increasing 50% year over year. Its credit portfolio grew 75% to $16.4 billion, while advertising revenue increased 73%.
Growth also comes with risks
MercadoLibre, Inc. is choosing to reinvest heavily in shipping, credit, payments, and customer acquisition rather than maximize current profits. Its operating margin was only 6.7% in Q2, down sharply from a year earlier. The company believes these investments will make the ecosystem more valuable over time, but investors still have to accept the risk that credit losses, weaker consumer spending or higher operating costs could prevent that investment from translating into much higher profits.
Shopify has a different risk. Its business is cleaner, but 58.82x forward earnings leaves much less room for a slowdown. The company is growing quickly today, but the market is already assuming that this growth will remain strong as Shopify gets larger.
That makes the valuation comparison especially important.
MercadoLibre is actually growing faster, while Shopify is more profitable on a cash-flow basis and has a less complicated balance sheet. It is understandable to pay a premium for Shopify’s cleaner model, but a premium of this size requires a lot.
Conclusion
Shopify may have the cleaner business, but MercadoLibre looks more attractive at these valuations. At 32.79x forward earnings, investors are paying much less for a company growing revenue at 50% while building an increasingly valuable commerce and fintech ecosystem. Shopify can justify its premium, but it has much less room for disappointment.
Market Sentiment
According to Insider Monkey’s database, 107 hedge funds held MercadoLibre in Q2, up from 102 in Q1, while the value of those positions increased from $7.83 billion to $9.02 billion. Both the number of funds and the capital invested moved higher, suggesting stronger institutional confidence in the stock.
Meanwhile, 82 hedge funds held Shopify in Q2, down from 88 in Q1, while the value of those positions increased from $4.38 billion to $5.44 billion. The decline in fund ownership was offset by a sizable increase in the value of holdings, making sentiment somewhat mixed.
READ NEXT: Amazon (AMZN) and Apple (AAPL) Must Face a UK Class Action Over Marketplace Sales and What is eBay’s (EBAY) Economic Moat, and is it Widening or Narrowing?
This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
