5 Highest Quality Butter Brands in the US

3. Challenge

Insider Monkey Score: 7

Established in 1911, Challenge has been producing superior quality butter ever since. The reason why Challenge Butter is recognized as one of the most essential staples in kitchens is their use of 100% real and natural pasteurized sweet cream. Their commitment to using only natural ingredients and no synthetic flavors or artificial additives still remains unchanged even after a century. Additionally, the significant content of butterfat gives it a creamy texture, making it an ideal choice for baking and cooking.