This article takes a look at the 5 highest quality butter brands in the US. If you wish to check out our detailed analysis on the butter industry, you may go to 15 Highest Quality Butter Brands in the US.
5. Plugra
Insider Monkey Score: 6
Plugra, with its Premium European Style Butter, is one of the best butter brands in the United States. The high-quality dairy products, especially its unique butter with 82% butter fat, makes it a trustworthy choice for every household. Plugra butter is ideal for baking as it is produced using a meticulous process which enhances its blending qualities, resulting in a perfect baking experience every single time.
4. Vital Farms
Insider Monkey Score: 6
Vital Farms, one of highest quality butter brands in the United States, is highly notable in American households due to the unique qualities of its butter. The Vital Farms butter gets its rich, creamy flavor from the fresh-cream used in its making. Sourced from cows raised on family farms, this cream contains a very high content of 85% butterfat. It is among the first few brands which introduced pasture-raised butter in the United States. The use of high-quality ingredients to produce both Salted and Unsalted butter, ensures that you get a flavorful and tasty spread each time.
3. Challenge
Insider Monkey Score: 7
Established in 1911, Challenge has been producing superior quality butter ever since. The reason why Challenge Butter is recognized as one of the most essential staples in kitchens is their use of 100% real and natural pasteurized sweet cream. Their commitment to using only natural ingredients and no synthetic flavors or artificial additives still remains unchanged even after a century. Additionally, the significant content of butterfat gives it a creamy texture, making it an ideal choice for baking and cooking.
2. Land O’ Lakes
Insider Monkey Score: 11
Land O’ Lakes is a 102 year old butter brand that remains an established choice of home cooks and professional chefs alike. But what makes this brand such a popular choice? Not only does Land O’ Lakes produce premium quality butter with a high amount of butterfat making it ideal for a versatile range of cooking practices, but it also caters to an extensive range of culinary preferences by offering multiple flavors. A little goes a long way. This saying holds true for Land O’ Lakes butter with its impressive shelf life. But that’s not the only distinguishing feature of their butter. It is also certified as gluten-free, making it a perfect alternative for people with celiac disease.
1. Kerrygold
Insider Monkey Score: 13
With a high butterfat content of about 82%, Kerrygold butter possesses a richer, creamier texture, and a much more enhanced flavor than most American butter brands. The secret of their premium butter lies in the cream used for its production. It is sourced from grass-fed cows all the way from Ireland, a place renowned for the production of high-quality milk, attributed to its ideal climate and vast grasslands. The high-quality milk is then churned longer than any other regular butter, thus making it more tasty and rich in nutrients. A winner of the 2023 PEOPLE Food Awards for its herb-flavored butter, Kerrygold is the number 1 Highest Quality Butter Brand in the United States in our list.
Insider Monkey focuses on uncovering the best investment ideas of hedge funds and insiders. Please subscribe to our free daily newsletter to get the latest investment ideas from hedge funds’ investor letters by entering your email address below. You can also take a peek at 15 Highest Quality Affordable Watch Brands and 30 Cities With The Best Hospitals In The US.
