5 Highest Quality Butter Brands in the US

4. Vital Farms

Insider Monkey Score: 6

Vital Farms, one of highest quality butter brands in the United States, is highly notable in American households due to the unique qualities of its butter. The Vital Farms butter gets its rich, creamy flavor from the fresh-cream used in its making. Sourced from cows raised on family farms, this cream contains a very high content of 85% butterfat. It is among the first few brands which introduced pasture-raised butter in the United States. The use of high-quality ingredients to produce both Salted and Unsalted butter, ensures that you get a flavorful and tasty spread each time.