Since then, the company has received a downgrade from Wells Fargo, Barrons, and Goldman Sachs. However, what was interesting to note was that Deere & Company (NYSE:DE) got the maximum punishment — neither AGCO Corporation (NYSE:AGCO) nor CNH Global NV (NYSE:CNH) saw that big a decline since Deere’s fall.
Why has that happened?
Deere’s earnings call and analyst takeaways
Deere’s shares tumbled after management gave a cautious outlook on not just the world economy, but adverse weather patterns.
“Cool wet weather in North America has delayed crop planting, slowed construction activity and hurt sales of turf-care equipment.”
Similarly, Well Fargo’s analyst claimed that U.S. crop cash flow was expected to decline 8% in 2013. Since farmers’ income is positively correlated with farm machinery demand, this is likely to hamper sales of agricultural machinery. Barron’s also pointed out that:
“As goes the North American corn crop, so goes Deere & Company (NYSE:DE)’s stock price.”
Goldman’s analyst further elaborated that recovering commodity inventories point to lower U.S. farm income and capex. He pointed out that U.S. dealer inventories are 17% above historical levels and farmer capex and capital stock are at their peaks. He suggested that though Deere is expected to return cash to its shareholders through 2014 (buybacks worth $2.2 billion), yet it will still bring about an EPS below the consensus estimates. Hence, Deere & Company (NYSE:DE) is recommended as a sell.
What about AGCO?
Deere & Company (NYSE:DE) witnessed a strong Latin American market as the revenue of the company rose 48% in that region. Many have suggest a bullish thesis on Deere given a strong Latin American agriculture market. However, in this context, Wells Fargo analyst commented that if strong Latin American demand is now the bullish thesis, then investors should better invest in AGCO Corporation (NYSE:AGCO) that gives a better exposure to that market.
Deere & Company (NYSE:DE) gets 34% of its revenue from outside North America but it doesn’t disclose how much it gets from Latin America. The Street tells us that its exposure to Latin America is not that high.
However, a strong exposure to the Latin American market might not mean that the stock is a straightaway buy. There are some other things to consider as well.
The company has heavy exposure to agriculture in Europe (~50% of revenue) where the fundamentals are flat to up slightly at best. Since this has been the situation for quite some time, it is quite a chance that softness in that market has already been priced into the stock.
Strong conditions in South America (~20% of revenue) do provide some hope to investors. However, it is interesting to note that AGCO Corporation (NYSE:AGCO) continues to lose share in Brazil, which has been the fastest growing area in that region.
