Every so often, a decades-old company gets recognized for a track record most investors have stopped thinking about. A Wall Street Journal analysis recently found that The Home Depot, Inc. (NYSE:HD) has been the highest-returning U.S. stock of the past 45 years. It turned a $1,000 investment made at its 1981 IPO into roughly $16 million by 2026, a 24% compound annual return that edges out Apple’s roughly 20% annual return over a similar span. Aggressive buybacks played a major role: Home Depot’s share count fell from 2.345 billion in fiscal 2001 to 998 million by August 2026, boosting per-share returns along the way. For investors, the harder question is what a 45-year record actually tells you about the next five.
Look Into: The Home Depot (HD) Posts Record Sales Growth Amid CEO Leave
Bull Case
The Home Depot, Inc. (NYSE:HD)’s decades-long buyback discipline has really shrunk its share count over time. Fewer shares outstanding means even modest earnings growth translates into outsized per-share gains. That is a structural tailwind that keeps working in shareholders’ favor as long as the company keeps repurchasing stock.
The company still benefits from scale that helps purchasing, distribution, and service for both customers and professional contractors. Those advantages protect its category leadership. It also gives Home Depot a strong platform to resume earnings growth when housing turnover and large renovation activity recover.
Home Depot has been investing through the housing slowdown by building its professional-contractor platform around SRS Distribution and the $4.3 billion agreement to acquire GMS. The combined network would exceed 1,200 locations and 8,000 delivery trucks. It gives Home Depot a concrete route to recurring, higher-value professional sales beyond the growth limits of its mature warehouse footprint.
Bear Case
The 45-year return describes what The Home Depot, Inc. (NYSE:HD) already achieved. It is not what new investors can expect from its current size and valuation. A business with a mature national footprint cannot repeat its early store expansion at the same rate. Hence, future returns must depend more heavily on comparable sales, margins, and capital allocation.
Recent operating data show that challenge. Comparable sales rose only 1.7% in the latest quarter while transactions fell 1%, which means higher average spending helped growth as customer traffic weakened. High interest rates and a slow housing market limit the large remodeling projects that drive important parts of Home Depot’s business.
Home Depot stopped buying back its own shares to fund major acquisitions. This shows that the share-count reduction behind much of its past profit growth can pause when management spends cash elsewhere. If these acquisitions fail to earn strong returns or housing demand stays weak, investors will lose out. They will lose both buyback support and the steady growth needed to justify the stock’s strong reputation.
Hedge Fund Sentiment
The Home Depot, Inc. (NYSE:HD)’s hedge fund count fell to 98 in the second quarter of 2026 from 100 in the first, even as position value rose to $11.68 billion from $9.08 billion, according to Insider Monkey’s database. Lowe’s, its closest direct competitor, saw holders rise slightly to 69 from 66, with position value holding roughly flat at $1.81 billion versus $1.82 billion.
Conclusion
Home Depot’s record shows a rare combination of category leadership, operating expansion, and aggressive share repurchases. Those strengths still matter. However, the company’s current scale, soft transaction growth, and paused buybacks make the historical return an explanation rather than a forecast. Investors should look into whether housing demand, acquisition returns, and renewed capital returns can restart per-share growth from today’s much larger base.
READ NEXT: Retailers are Handling Tariff Refunds in Very Different Ways: Walmart and Home Depot and Target (TGT)’s Comeback Quarter had Nearly $1 Billion in Help From Trump’s Tariff Refunds
Hedge Fund Resource Center