McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD) was trading at around $232 on October 5, down 21.67% over twelve months and close to its 52-week low of $229.20.
Its book value per share is negative $1.45. On paper, the company’s liabilities exceed its assets. That is not distress. It is the result of a decision taken repeatedly over many years.
READ ALSO: Costco (COST) vs Walmart (WMT): Which is a Better Stock to Buy?
The Equity Was Bought Back, Not Lost:
A company erases its own equity in one of two ways. It loses money for years, or it buys back stock. McDonald’s earned $8.79 billion on a 31.72% net margin, so it is not the first. The second is a choice, and the operating margin explains why management felt able to make it. At 46.49%, McDonald’s keeps nearly half of every dollar that comes through the door.
No restaurant operator earns that. McDonald’s does because most of the restaurants belong to franchisees, and what it collects is rent and royalties rather than the proceeds of selling food.
Royalty income is predictable, and predictable income can be borrowed against. Buy back stock with the proceeds for long enough, and the equity line goes below zero by design. Free cash flow of $6.26 billion against $8.79 billion of profit is the test that it still works.
DON’T MISS: Is Best Buy’s (BBY) Moat Narrowing as Electronics Move Online for Good?
What the Structure Costs:
The structure works until the royalties wobble, and that is exactly what the growth line is now testing. Revenue grew 3.70% and earnings 4.80%. For a company with no equity and $54.6 billion of debt against $822 million of cash, slow growth is not merely disappointing. It is the only thing between the royalty stream and the interest bill.
The market has noticed. The shares have fallen 21.67% and sit near a 52-week low, with the 50-day average of $259.25 well below the 200-day at $289.81. The dividend tightens it further, taking 59.71% of reported earnings before a dollar goes to buybacks.
One consequence is that the usual checks do not work. No price-to-book figure exists, and no return on equity figure exists, because both need a positive denominator, which leaves return on assets at 13.25% doing the work of two missing measures. A 3.33% yield is the compensation for a balance sheet with nothing underneath it. Ten dividend stocks beat the market this year, and we ranked them here.
The Valuation Case:
People eat at these restaurants in good years and bad, which is why beta is 0.45 and why the royalty stream supports the borrowing at all. On price, the fall has done some work, taking the trailing multiple to 19.36 times from 26.08 times at the end of last year.
Enterprise value to EBITDA of 18.81 is the honest figure, because it counts the $54.6 billion of debt that the earnings multiple ignores. A PEG ratio of 2.06 states the problem in one number. The price is roughly twice the growth rate. Ten stocks positioned for high returns in 2026 are named here.
Conclusion:
The negative equity is a choice rather than a warning. A 46.49% operating margin on rent and royalties is predictable enough to borrow against, and McDonald’s bought back its own stock with the proceeds. However, the choice assumes the royalties keep growing, and they are growing 3.70% while $54.6 billion of debt sits against $822 million of cash. The shares have fallen 21.67% and still cost 18.81 times enterprise value to EBITDA. The number to watch is comparable store sales, because nothing else is holding this structure up.
Market Sentiment:
McDonald’s Corporation was held by 79 hedge funds with a combined stake value of about $4.01 billion at the end of Q2 2026 in the Insider Monkey database. This is down from 83 hedge fund holders with a cumulative investment value of around $4.96 billion in the previous quarter.
READ NEXT: Costco (COST) vs Walmart (WMT): Which is a Better Stock to Buy? and Is Best Buy’s (BBY) Moat Narrowing as Electronics Move Online for Good?
This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
Hedge Fund Resource Center