On August 4, Spotify (NYSE:SPOT) and Merlin announced a licensing agreement that lets independent artists opt into Spotify’s upcoming fan-made covers and remixing tool. It sounds like a minor feature rollout, but the stock has been under pressure for most of the year, and this is one of several engagement bets management is leaning on to justify a valuation that still assumes real growth ahead.
Bull Case: A New Way To Get Paid For Old Songs
The tool itself is a paid add-on, which means every remix or cover made through it becomes a fresh revenue line for participating artists rather than just another free listen. Charlie Hellman, Spotify’s SVP and Global Head of Music, said the Merlin agreement “ensures participating artists are credited and compensated, and that every creation drives listeners back to the original work.” Merlin CEO Charlie Lexton framed it as giving member artists the choice to join while protecting their rights. Because Merlin represents independent labels covering 15% of the global recorded music market, the deal stretches the tool well past the major labels and into a huge swath of working artists.
It also fits a pattern. Spotify has spent the year layering AI-driven engagement features on top of its catalog, including Prompted Playlist, AI DJ, and a newly rolled out Running Mode that builds workout playlists by tempo. The financial backdrop supports the strategy. Second-quarter revenue rose 14% year-over-year to ~$5.56 billion, driven by 300 million premium subscribers and 494 million ad-supported users. Net income reached ~$634 million, reversing the prior year’s loss and proving the engagement push is successfully boosting paid adoption. Monthly active users, premium subscribers, and sales all grew at double-digit or near-double-digit rates in the latest quarter, showing the engagement push is translating into paying customers rather than just headlines.
Bear Case: The Insider Sale And The Price Tag
Not everything points up. Co-CEO Gustav Soderstrom sold 20,833 shares on August 3, worth $10.6 million at a weighted average price of $507.24, cutting his direct holdings by 51%. The sale was automatic, executed under a Rule 10b5-1 plan set up back on December 11, 2025, so it isn’t a timing signal, and Soderstrom still holds 125,463 derivative securities plus his remaining shares. Still, a 51% cut in direct holdings is the kind of headline that makes shareholders pause.
The bigger question is valuation. Spotify’s stock is down 37% from its peak and 29% over the past year as sales growth has decelerated, yet it still isn’t cheap. A newly launched, paid add-on like the remix tool also carries real execution risk. Licensing agreements are one thing, but getting fans to actually pay to remix songs, and getting labels comfortable with how those remixes circulate, is a different test entirely.
What The Market Is Pricing In
Hedge fund ownership rose from 121 funds to 123 in the most recent quarter, a mild sign of accumulating interest rather than an exodus. Short interest sits at 4.15% of float, which points to a modest bear camp rather than heavy organized skepticism. The stock’s forward P/E of 35.34, as of August 11, tells a different story, though, one where the market is still paying up for growth even as subscriber and revenue gains cool from their earlier pace.
Conclusion
The remix deal and Spotify’s broader AI feature set are genuine attempts to deepen engagement and open new revenue streams beyond the subscription check. But an elevated forward multiple leaves little room for error if adoption of these paid extras disappoints.
While we acknowledge the risk and potential of SPOT as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and doing so within a shorter time frame. If you are looking for an AI stock that is more promising than SPOT and that has 10,000% upside potential, check out our report about this cheapest AI stock.
READ NEXT: 10 Best Future Stocks to Buy Under $10 and 12 Best Performing Semiconductor Stocks to Invest In.
Disclosure: None. Follow Insider Monkey on Google News.
Hedge Fund Resource Center