Salesforce, Inc. (NYSE:CRM) fell roughly 4% and ServiceNow, Inc. (NYSE:NOW) lost about 5% on September 8 as GPT-6 Astra revived fears that general AI agents will compete with specialist software. The selloff priced a real threat, but “extinction” ignores where these companies still control the work.
OpenAI launched Astra on September 3 with improvements in coding, research and computer use, explicitly designing it to operate software. If a general agent can complete tasks across applications, companies may need fewer expensive seats and less custom workflow code. Procurement teams can also compare an agent’s outcome cost with each application’s license price. That pressure reaches Salesforce’s sales and service products and ServiceNow’s IT and employee workflows.
Agents can compress seats and expand consumption
Salesforce’s defense is its customer data and installed workflows. Its latest quarterly revenue rose 11% to $11.3 billion, while Agentforce ARR exceeded $1.5 billion after increasing 240%. Agentforce and Data 360 together approached $3.9 billion of ARR, and agentic work units grew 97% sequentially to 3.2 billion. Salesforce already mixes per-user licensing with consumption through Flex Credits and per-conversation pricing, giving it a route to monetize work even if seats flatten.
The bear case is cannibalization: cheaper independent agents can sit above Salesforce, reduce seat growth and turn applications into interchangeable systems of record. Consumption revenue must then outrun pressure on traditional subscriptions.
ServiceNow has a similar advantage in governed enterprise processes. Second-quarter subscription revenue grew 24.5% to $3.88 billion, current remaining performance obligations reached $13.20 billion, and ServiceNow AI crossed $1 billion in annual contract value. Its production context and permissions can make a general model safer inside large organizations.
Yet Astra can also weaken the interface layer through which ServiceNow differentiates itself. Customers may demand lower prices if agents perform tasks without navigating each product’s screens.
Insider Monkey’s hedge fund database counted 99 CRM holders in Q2 2026, down from 101 in Q1; Harris Associates owned 16,151,269 shares after increasing its position 9%. NOW holders rose to 115 from 108, while Fisher Asset Management held 8,018,318 shares after a 1% reduction. Those quarter-end positions preceded Astra’s launch.
As of August 31, 29,211,825 CRM shares were sold short, equal to 3.68% of float and 1.50 days of average volume. Of course short-interest figures also preceded Astra’s launch. The September 8 selloff shows investors are pricing renewed disruption risk, but extinction requires agents to replace proprietary data, controls and outcomes as well as the interface, and the companies’ own AI growth shows that verdict remains unsettled.
READ NEXT: The Trillion-Dollar AI Capex Gap: Why Too Much Hardware Could Be Nvidia’s Trap and Microsoft’s Opportunity and Redditors Are Skeptical of SpaceX’s Orbital Data Centers. Are They Right?
