Google Inc (GOOG) Made A Giant Mistake

Page 1 of 2

Google Inc.It’s been nearly two years since Google Inc (NASDAQ:GOOG) shocked the mobile world by announcing its intention to acquire Motorola Mobility for an incredible $12.5 billion. With such a hefty price tag, the proposed deal would inevitably spark endless debate over whether or not it was a smart move to acquire a struggling hardware vendor with a vast patent portfolio.

Nearly a year after the announcement, the pair would score all necessary regulatory approvals and seal the deal in May 2012. The final price tag ended up being closer to $12.4 billion, and this is how Big G pegged the value of the assets it acquired at the time.

Asset Valuation
Cash $2.9 billion
Patents and developed technology $5.5 billion
Goodwill $2.6 billion
Customer relationships $730 million
Other net assets $670 million
Total $12.4 billion

Source: 10-Q.

When factoring in the cash that Google Inc (NASDAQ:GOOG) bought, its net cost was $9.5 billion, and the bulk of that is allocated to the patent portfolio. The $5.5 billion valuation was much higher than the $137 million book value that Motorola was carrying for its IP, but that was net of accumulated amortization, and GAAP accounting rules don’t permit revaluing intangible assets higher.

Google Inc (NASDAQ:GOOG) also sold off the Motorola Home business to Arris Group, Inc. (NASDAQ:ARRS) in a $2.4 billion cash and stock deal, which closed this month. Big G is now the proud owner of a 7.7% stake in Arris, while its net cost for Motorola subsequently declined to around $7.1 billion.

In the four quarters since closing the deal, Motorola’s actual hardware operations have continued to bleed. Motorola posts hundreds of millions of GAAP operating losses every quarter, and has cost Google a cumulative total of $1.4 billion so far just by operating.

Sorry, Google Inc (GOOG). You Made a Huge Mistake.

Source: SEC filings.

We can effectively increase Google’s net cost back up to $8.5 billion, and Motorola’s operating losses have no sign of abating anytime soon. Even if Googorola’s upcoming “phones-plus” are a hit, the subsidiary still might not be profitable.

The star of the acquisition has always been the patent portfolio, but even on that front Google has had a pretty terrible month so far. Motorola is embroiled in numerous patent disputes with rivals Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) and Microsoft Corporation (NASDAQ:MSFT) , and things aren’t going Google Inc (NASDAQ:GOOG)’s way. The search giant scored some victories, but also recorded more meaningful defeats.

Page 1 of 2