Goldcorp Inc. (USA) (GG), Gold Fields Limited (ADR) (GFI): Have Gold Miners Lost Their Luster?

It’s been an awful start to the year for investors in gold miners. Shares of both Goldcorp Inc. (USA) (NYSE:GG) and Gold Resource Corporation (NYSEMKT:GORO) hit 52-week lows this week while many other gold miners have seen their shares dive this year. Take a quick look at this year-to-date performance chart of a basket of gold stocks and you’ll see what I mean:

GG Chart

GG data by YCharts

I hope you didn’t stare at that chart too long; it’s pretty brutal. What happened, and is now time to invest in these gold miners?

Lost its luster
Gold, which is viewed by many investors as a safe haven just hasn’t been needed in recent weeks. The precious metal hit a 10-month low earlier this week as signs continue to point to a strengthening economy. It’s also quite possible that we’re becoming immune to bad news.

European fears of a contagion from Cyprus eased almost as quickly as they flared up. Even sabre rattling from North Korea hasn’t seemed to strike too much fear into the markets when that country supposedly has the capabilities to wipe Los Angeles off the map.You’d think that would have people buying gold and running for the hills.

Amid all this, overall investor interest in gold has fallen to the point that Credit Suisse Group AG (ADR) (NYSE:CS) has cut its price prediction for gold to $1,580 an ounce this year and $1,500 an ounce for next year. Given that gold is the contrarian’s investment of choice, now just might be time to be that contrarian and buy a gold miner. The hard part is determining which gold miner to buy.

Now on sale
While it hasn’t fallen as far as some of the names on my dismal chart from above, Goldcorp Inc. (USA) (NYSE:GG) is viewed by many as being the gold standard when it comes to gold investments. That being said, if you like income you might want to look at Gold Resource Corporation (NYSEMKT:GORO) as it pays a high monthly dividend. You’re options don’t end there — Barrick Gold Corporation (USA) (NYSE:ABX) offers investors the opportunity to invest in one of the world’s largest pure gold mining companies. As you can see, it gets complicated very quickly.

That’s why I think a lot of investors might be drawn to a company that simply enables you to profit from the price appreciate of gold. By taking away the operational risks that can tarnish the names I just mentioned, gold streamer Sandstorm Gold is a company that’s worth a deeper look. The company has a management team that’s experienced in streaming and a diversified production base that should yield long-term returns.

Moving away from operational risks is more important than you’d think. Take Gold Fields Limited (ADR) (GFI) (NYSE:GFI) for example, the company’s operations at its two mines in Ghana were halted recently after a strike broke out over a pay dispute. This isn’t the first time the company has been hit by labor unrest as a 23-day strike shut the company’s South African mines last year. Halting production can really impact the bottom line, which is one reason why the company’s shares have of been the worst performing of the bunch.