Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (NYSE:CM) Q4 2022 Earnings Call Transcript

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (NYSE:CM) Q4 2022 Earnings Call Transcript December 1, 2022

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce misses on earnings expectations. Reported EPS is $1.39 EPS, expectations were $1.72.

Operator: Good morning and welcome to the CIBC Quarterly Financial Results Call. Please be advised that this call is being recorded. I would now like to turn the meeting over to Geoff Weiss, Senior Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead, Geoff.

Geoff Weiss: Thank you and good morning. We will begin this morning’s presentation with opening remarks from Victor Dodig, our President and Chief Executive Officer followed by Hratch Panossian, our Chief Financial Officer; and Frank Guse, our Chief Risk Officer. Also on the call today are a number of our group heads, including Shawn Beber, U.S. Region; Harry Culham, Capital Markets and Direct Financial Services; Laura Dottori-Attanasio, Canadian Personal and Business Banking; and Jon Hountalas, Canadian Commercial Banking and Wealth Management. They are all available to take questions following the prepared remarks. With a hard stop at 8:30, please limit your questions to one. As noted on Slide 2 of our investor presentation, our comments may contain forward-looking statements, which include assumptions and have inherent risks and uncertainties. Actual results may differ materially. With that, I will now turn the call over to Victor.

Victor Dodig: Thank you, Geoff and good morning everyone. My remarks this morning will focus on our performance and achievements over the past year and our outlook for the year ahead. But before I get into these details, I wanted to acknowledge members of our CIBC leadership team who are taking on new roles as we start our new fiscal year. Mike Capatides, most recently the Head of our U.S. Region, has transitioned to the role of Vice Chair, CIBC Bank USA. With more than 25 years of banking experience, Mike is going to focus on developing and deepening client relationships in our U.S. region. Shawn Bieber, most recently, our Chief Risk Officer, succeeds Mike. Shawn was instrumental in the acquisition of the Private Bank in 2017.

And with his deep knowledge of our U.S. business, strong client focus and proven execution in senior leadership roles across our bank, he will continue building on our momentum in leading our U.S. region. I am also pleased to introduce Frank Guse as our new Chief Risk Officer. Some of you may be familiar with Frank from his most recent role leading strategy and transformation in personal and business banking. Frank’s global expertise in all facets of risk management, coupled with a strategic perspective, position him well for his new role. These leadership changes leverage our strong and experienced internal talent and they allow us to focus on delivering relative outperformance going forward. But turning to our adjusted fiscal 2022 full year results, revenue of $21.8 billion was up 9% and pre-provision pre-tax earnings of $9.4 billion was up 7% from last year.

These results were driven by robust volume growth across all our businesses, which was a direct result of the continued execution of our client-focused strategy and the investments that we are making in growth, which will benefit our business in fiscal 2023 and beyond. Adjusted net earnings of $6.6 billion or $7.05 per share were down 2% from the prior year, mainly a result of more normal credit provisions coming off the year of performing credit releases in fiscal 2021. The credit quality of our portfolio remains strong with impaired provisions down 1% compared to last year. Now operating leverage was negative in fiscal 2022 and it relates to the investments we made this year in our current and future growth capabilities. While our structural expense growth remained in the mid single-digits, investments in strategic initiatives as well as employee-related compensation and a normalization of business development activities drove year-over-year expense growth of 11%.

Our accelerated investments in growth were essential to strengthen our market position and to generate the strong top line results we are seeing across our business units. With many of our key strategic and compensation-related investments come now completed, we are now shifting to more moderate expense growth in 2023 to the mid single-digit range, as we have previously conveyed to you. Our capital position remains strong with a CET1 ratio of 11.7%, while our return on equity for the year was 14.7%. We are also announcing a $0.02 dividend increase to our common shareholders while maintaining our payout ratio between 40% and 50%. Reflecting back on fiscal 2022, we made a lot of progress as we continued on our client-focused journey. At the enterprise level, we are delivering on our three key strategic priorities that we have laid out at Investor Day.

That’s the focus on high growth, high touch segments where we are well-positioned in making notable progress, elevating the banking experience for our clients through investments in technology and further increasing connectivity across our bank. And we are investing in future growth differentiators, particularly in our Innovation Banking franchise, our fin-tech capabilities and renewable energy platform. As well, in support of our net-zero ambition, we announced 2030 interim targets to reduce the carbon intensity of finance submissions in our oil and gas and power generation portfolios. In Canadian Personal & Business Banking, we demonstrated positive momentum with our strongest client growth since 2017, where we added over 350,000 net new clients to our bank, 38% of which are from the affluent segment, almost 3x the index of our market share in that segment.

In addition to this, we successfully transitioned over 2 million Costco co-brand card clients. And while it’s still early days, we have already deepened our banking relationship with over 30,000 of these new card clients to hold additional CIBC products and services. Again, these clients also tilt heavily to the affluent segment. Our client growth and success in franchising drove year-over-year deposit and asset growth of 9% and 12% respectively, which resulted in market share gains versus the big 6 Canadian bank peer group. Contributing to these positive outcomes is our relentless focus on living our purpose and that’s to help our make our clients’ ambitions a reality. And we have done that by introducing enhanced digital tools for both our retail and business banking clients, underpinned by a focus on advice for the long term.

And our efforts for this were rewarded with the second place ranking in the J.D. Power Client Satisfaction Survey and being recognized for delivering outstanding digital client experience by digital banker. Our Canadian Commercial Banking and Wealth Management business also demonstrated strong momentum throughout 2022, with loan and deposit growth of 20% and 12%, respectively, along with higher net wealth flows. In Commercial Banking, we continued to expand programs tailored to high growth industries, modernize our systems and streamline our processes to support enriched client conversations. In Private Wealth, we have added new planning professionals to further support our integrated wealth franchise and we launched a series of exclusive private banking offers.

The net result is a record year of net inflows with our CIBC Wood Gundy franchise, which were up 27% compared to the prior year. Our private wealth offering is underpinned by the strength of our investment advisers and private bankers. This year, 30 of CIBC Wood Gundy’s advisers were named to Canada’s top wealth advisers listed by the Global Mail. And in Asset Management, we incorporated a climate policy in our responsible investing policy as we continue to focus on sustainability and our investment strategies. Despite industry challenges impacting net flows across all big 6 Canadian banks CIBC was ranked third and long-term mutual fund net flows as a percent of AUM. Our U.S. Commercial Banking and Wealth Management franchise made significant technology and infrastructure investments in the business and that’s to support our above-market growth now and going forward.

In 2022, we had strong loan growth. It was up 15% and three quarters of that was originated from new client relationships. Our focus on the private economy and high-growth client segments also drove strong client growth of 6% in wealth and private banking funds. Our efforts to build a best-in-class U.S. private wealth franchise were recognized again by Barron’s who ranked us as a top 10 registered investment adviser for the third consecutive year. In Capital Markets, our differentiated business model continued to deliver results. Our focus on strong cross-bank connectivity and growing our U.S. presence was rewarded with revenue growth from non-traditional capital markets clients of 14% and from the U.S. of 17%. We also made strategic investments in high-growth areas, including the expansion of our renewables and energy transition industry vertical.

In 2022, we were the recipient of Global Finance’s North American regional awards for outstanding leadership in green bonds in transition and sustainability-linked bonds. We also continued to rank in the top 10 in North America for financings in the renewables industry as tracked in information’s most recent league tables, notable accomplishments in our capital markets business. As we look ahead to 2023, global economic growth is expected to be slower as central banks continue with their monetary policy tightening to tame inflation. And in response to these headwinds, and as I just mentioned earlier in my remarks, we are going to continue to take actions to reposition our business to adjust to these new realities, but also continue to grow our client franchise and moderate our expense growth in 2023 to the mid single-digit range.

While we can’t control the environment, we can control our execution. We have successfully navigated through challenging circumstances in the past and we are confident in our ability to do so going forward. And with that, I would like to pass the call over to Hratch. Over to you, Hratch.

See also 12 Best Momentum Stocks To Buy and 10 Best Young Stocks To Buy and Hold Forever.

Hratch Panossian: Thank you, Victor and good morning to you all. I will begin my remarks with a review of our fourth quarter on Slide 9 before covering the highlights of fiscal 2022 and providing some color on our expectations going forward. Against the deteriorating backdrop, we reported earnings per share of $1.26 for the fourth quarter, down 18% from the prior year, primarily due to higher provisions for credit losses. Excluding the items of note detailed in the appendix to our presentation, adjusted EPS was $1.39. While market and economic headwinds impacted our financial results this quarter, we maintained a strong balance sheet and made meaningful progress against our strategic priorities. We continue to be focused on driving long-term stakeholder value and remain committed to delivering on our medium-term financial targets.

To that end, while still early days, I will reference our progress against key targets laid out at our June Investor Day during my remarks on segment results. The balance of my presentation will refer to adjusted results, which exclude items of note, starting with Slide 10. Adjusted net income of $1.3 billion for the quarter was down 17% from the prior year driven primarily by a provision for credit losses against performing loans this quarter as compared to a provision released last year. This was predominantly the result of a change in economic outlook, as Frank will cover in further detail later in our presentation. Pre-provision pre-tax earnings of $2.1 billion were down 2% from a year ago largely due to elevated expenses, which were up 12% from the prior year, including the impact of inflation and severance charges in this quarter.

Revenue of $5.4 billion was up 6%, driven by strong volume growth across all businesses and solid trading partly offset by lower market-related fees. Slide 11 highlights the drivers of net interest income. Excluding trading, NII was up 12% from last year, supported by strong loan and deposit growth across our franchise. Excluding trading, total bank NIM was down 7 basis points sequentially and was comparable to the prior year as changes in certain product margins and mix across our balance sheet more than offset the benefit of rising interest rates. While we are seeing a shift in client preference towards term deposits, a substantial portion of our indeterminate maturity deposits are non-interest-bearing or low cost and will continue to benefit from rising rates.

We anticipate continued growth in non-trading NII supported by volume and the continued upward trend in deposit margins if interest rates stabilize at current levels or higher. Slide 12 details the changes in key segment margins. Our consistent approach across Canada and the U.S. is to position the balance sheet in a manner that stabilizes margins and supports more predictable net interest income through changes in interest rates. As shown on the slide, we have benefited from that approach through the recent period of lower rates and will continue to benefit steadily from higher interest rates going forward. This quarter, Canadian P&C NIM declined 4 basis points sequentially. Higher deposit margins benefited from the impact of rising interest rates on the more than 40% of indeterminate maturity deposits in this segment that are non-interest sensitive.

This was more than offset by lower margins on recent mortgage originations and lower mortgage prepayment activity. NIM in our U.S. segment was up 13 basis points relative to last quarter, or 8 basis points, excluding CRA investment gains, which are episodic. Excluding these gains, the core NIM increased primarily due to higher deposit margins, which benefited from higher interest rates partly offset by lower margins on loans. We continue to anticipate a positive NIM trajectory in the medium-term across both of these segments, helped by higher interest rates. However, we expect some continued pressure from Canadian mortgage origination spreads and lower non-interest-bearing deposit growth in the early part of 2023. Turning to Slide 13, non-interest income of $2.2 billion was up 6% from the prior year or down 3% excluding trading.

Market-related fees were up 5% driven by trading income and declined excluding trading predominantly due to lower fees from market-sensitive businesses, which were impacted by market deterioration. Transaction-related fees were generally stable over the prior quarter and up 5% from prior year driven by higher volume of client activity. Turning to Slide 14, expenses were up 12% year-over-year, including severance incurred in the quarter as we repositioned the business in response to the changing economic outlook. Excluding severance, year-over-year expense growth of 10% was lower than prior quarters in 2022 as our increase in strategic investment starts to peak. Approximately half of the 10% growth was related to higher investment on strategic initiatives discussed in the past.

Our base operating expenses were up 5% from the prior year, including the significant impact of inflation and they remain in the low single-digit range, excluding inflation. Our approach to expense management remains consistent, generating positive operating leverage in aggregate over the medium term, while continuing to invest to advance our strategic agenda. As such, we have taken proactive steps over the last several months, with actions that position us well for 2023, namely restricting discretionary expenses, pacing our investments and repositioning our team through the incurred severance and other actions. These actions will allow us to stabilize core expenses around this quarter’s levels, resulting in mid single-digit growth for the full year 2023 as we communicated in our Investor Day.

Turning to Slide 15, our balance sheet remains strong as we continue to focus on disciplined deployment of resources. We ended the quarter with a CET1 ratio of 11.7%, down 4 basis points from the prior quarter. The internal capital generation, almost covered growth in risk-weighted assets from organic growth and modest credit migration. We continue to expect strong internal capital generation to fund moderating RWA growth going forward, and our current capital level positions us well in the context of economic uncertainty. Our liquidity position strengthened this quarter supported by continued growth in deposits and moderating asset growth, resulting in a higher average LCR of 129%. Starting on Slide 16, we highlight our strategic business unit results.

Net income in Personal & Business Banking was $485 million, down 20% from the same quarter last year, primarily due to higher provisions for credit losses. Pre-provision pre-tax earnings of $968 million were down 2% from last year and revenue of $2.3 billion was up 6%. Our strategic focus in 2022 resulted in strong net client growth and franchising success, driving net client growth of over 350,000 as Victor covered and growth in loans and deposits of 12% and 9% respectively. Importantly, a large portion of our net client growth was in the affluent segment, where we continue to gain share. These new clients, along with over 2 million co-brand clients who transitioned to CIBC earlier this year are fueling our momentum. Expenses of $1.3 billion were up 13% from the same quarter last year and 3% sequentially, driven by higher strategic investments, including the impact of the acquired co-brand portfolio.

Moving on to Slide 17, net income in Canadian Commercial Banking and Wealth Management was $469 million, up 6% from the prior year. Pre-provision pre-tax earnings of $658 million were up 11% from last year benefiting from strong results in Commercial Banking that helped drive 28% growth in NII, net of market headwinds to our wealth management business. Our client-focused approach and ongoing investments underpin these financial results driving over $5 billion in referrals over fiscal €˜22 and support fund managed growth and net flows in private wealth. Slide 18 shows U.S. Commercial Banking and Wealth Management results in U.S. dollars, where we delivered net income of $125 million, down 42% from the prior year due to higher credit provisions.

Pre-provision pre-tax earnings of $232 million increased 3% from the prior year. Revenues were up 8% over this period due to an 18% growth in net interest income, partially offset by 12% decline in non-interest income largely related to the impact of market deterioration on wealth management fees. Over 2022, our strategy allowed us to grow and deepen our U.S. client franchise generating above-market loan and deposit growth 13%, 17% and 7% respectively as well as strong private wealth management net flows in a challenging market. Increased expenses were driven by ongoing investment to support our growing business and increasing regulatory requirements. We invested over $90 million in fiscal €˜22 to enhance our technology and infrastructure and to enable the next phase of our U.S. growth.

We expect these investments to moderate in 2023, resulting in the core expense base in this segment to stabilize starting around next quarter. Slide 19 speaks to our well-diversified and differentiated capital markets business. Net income of $378 million was in line with the prior year, while pre-provision pre-tax earnings of $526 million were up 9%. Revenues of $1.2 billion were up 17% over the year driven by strong performance across all lines of business. The differentiated elements of our capital markets business and our focused strategy continued to contribute to the strength of our results throughout 2022. In our high-growth DSS business, revenue was up 18% for the full year. And the contribution from our U.S. business, which benefits from connectivity with our commercial franchise, was up 17% on a full year basis.

Slide 20 reflects the results of the Corporate & Other business unit. Net loss of $197 million in the quarter compared to a net loss of $121 million in the same quarter last year, in large part due to market headwinds to treasury revenues and elevated expenses in the segment this quarter. Revenue was $147 million lower than the prior year, largely driven by higher funding and liquidity related costs in treasury, which were impacted by the increased cost of liquidity, as well as significant interest rate and FX volatility experienced in the quarter. Revenue in CIBC FirstCaribbean was strong, benefiting from volume growth and higher margins. Expenses were up 37% sequentially, including severance incurred in the quarter. Going forward, we maintain our guidance of $75 million to $125 million quarterly loss for this segment, but expect to be on the higher end of that range in the short-term.

Slide 21 highlights our full year financial results. As Victor mentioned in his opening remarks, notwithstanding a challenging fourth quarter, our fiscal €˜22 results were generally in line with our guidance and demonstrate our progress in executing our strategy. Revenue growth of 9% and pretax pre-provision earnings growth of 7% were both in line with our high single-digit guidance and our medium-term targets. Operating leverage was negative 2% for the year and below our target as a result of market revenue deterioration late in the year and the proactive measures we took this year to reposition our bank. Our intention is to offset this year’s results and generate positive operating leverage in aggregate through 2025. Adjusted ROE was 14.7%, generally in line with our target despite market pressures in the fourth quarter and a higher CET1 ratio than communicated at our Investor Day as a result of the current uncertain environment.

Turning to Slide 22, we have entered fiscal 2023 confident that we will continue to make progress against our client-focused strategy and deliver a resilient financial performance given our diverse business mix, conservative credit culture and strong capital position. Assuming the base economic outlook in our annual report, we continue to anticipate financial results consistent with our Investor Day targets through 2025, namely positive operating leverage, earnings CAGR of 7% to 10% and an ending ROE of 16% plus. We recognize, however, that the environment is uncertain and likely to be more challenging in 2023, and as a result, we’ve taken proactive measures to reposition our business as outlined by Victor in his remarks. In aggregate, we anticipate our plans to generate continued but moderating revenue growth through share gains, mid-single-digit expense growth and improving operating leverage for fiscal 2023.

I will now turn the call over to Frank.

Frank Guse: Thank you, Hratch and good morning everyone. Fiscal 2022 was a dynamic year in terms of the macroeconomic environment. Starting in Q2 of the year, we began increasing our allowance levels, reflecting the deteriorating environment. However, our credit performance remained strong throughout the year. Slide 24 details our provision for credit losses. Our total provision for credit loss was $436 million in Q4 compared with $243 million last quarter. The provision on impaired loans was $219 million in Q4. We experienced higher impaired provisions in both retail and business and government loans this quarter. In retail, higher impaired provisions were mainly due to an allowance increase as expected, reflective of higher delinquencies returning towards pre-COVID levels.

In business and government loans, high impaired provisions were largely attributable to our U.S. commercial portfolio, reflecting lower reversals this quarter, coupled with a few minor increases in Canadian Commercial and CIBC FirstCaribbean and lower reversals in capital markets. The provision on performing loans was $217 million in Q4, mainly driven by deterioration in our forward-looking indicators. Turning to Slide 25, we remain prudent in our allowances given the economic backdrop. We saw it increase 4 basis points to 62 basis points, mainly due to the increase in our performing allowance driven by the unfavorable change in our forward-looking indicators as I just mentioned, as well as higher impaired provisions incurred this quarter, which are still performing well overall.

Slide 26 focuses on our lending portfolio mix. Consistent with previous quarters, our portfolio reflects strong credit quality. Our total loan balances were $529 billion, of which 55% is real estate secured lending. Our variable rate mortgage portfolio accounts for a little over one-third of our mortgage portfolio and show strong credit quality and performance. The average loan-to-value for our uninsured mortgage portfolio was at 48%, which is down from 49% a year ago but up from 45% in Q3 as we have now seen a house price index drop in certain regions. The business and government portion of the portfolio has an average risk rating equivalent to a BBB, which has remained steady and continues to perform well. Slide 27 details our gross impaired loans.

Overall, gross impaired balances were up in Q4 with an increase in both retail and business and government loans. The increase is in line with our expectations. Despite the gross impaired dollar increase quarter-over-quarter, new formations remained stable and low from a historical perspective, and both the gross impaired loan ratio and new formations remain lower than our pre-pandemic run rate. Slide 28 details the net write-off and 90-day plus delinquency rates of our Canadian consumer portfolios. As expected, both net write-offs and delinquencies trended higher in Q4, with client activity continuing to revert towards pre-pandemic spending patterns. As has been noted in prior quarters, we continue to expect an increase in retail delinquencies and write-offs from the lows experienced in previous fiscal years and are well within those expectations.

Slide 29 provides an overview of our Canadian real estate secured personal lending portfolio. We continue to focus our origination efforts in this segment where clients have deep and balanced relationships with us. The majority of our mortgage growth over the last 2 years have been with clients where we have those relationships. 88% of mortgages are owner-occupied, with the balance being principally investor mortgages. Our late-stage delinquency rates across these portfolios continue to remain low and stable, with the Vancouver and Toronto portfolios outperforming our Canadian average. We will continue to take a prudent approach and are closely monitoring as interest rates rise and markets evolve. On Slide 30, we have included details on the portion of our mortgage portfolio that we will be renewing in the next 12 months.

Over that period, $20 billion of fixed rate and $8 billion of variable rate mortgages contractually come up for renewal. At this time, we still only see a small, less than $20 million of mortgage balances with clients we see as being at higher risk from a credit perspective and whose LTVs are in excess of 70%. These ratios are very stable quarter-over-quarter. We actively monitor our portfolios and proactively reach out to clients who are at high risk of financial stress. Slide 31 shows our FICO score and LTV distribution in our Canadian uninsured residential mortgage portfolio. The key takeaway is less than 1% of our uninsured mortgage portfolio has both score of 650 or less and an LTV over 75%. Overall, our mortgage portfolio is well positioned, and we do not expect to see material losses.

On Slide 32, we provide detail of our commercial real estate exposures in both Canada and the U.S. 68% of our Canadian portfolio and 34% of our U.S. portfolio are investment grade at the quarter end. We have prudent lending standards for our CRE exposures in both Canada and the U.S. with a strategic focus remaining on well-capitalized sponsors with strong track record and experience managing through economic cycles. Our exposures in both regions remain well diversified and continue to perform well. In closing, our performance is well in line with our expectations this quarter. Our credit portfolios are performing as expected, and we have strong coverage. And as economic conditions evolve, we continue to proactively work with our clients who are more at risk to provide solutions that ultimately drive positive outcomes.

I’ll now turn the call back to the operator.

Operator: Thank you. Our first question is from Ebrahim Poonawala from Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Ebrahim Poonawala: Good morning. I guess, actually, just following up, I think you mentioned your revenue growth expectation for €˜23. When we look at the mid-single-digit expense growth number, and I appreciate the uncertainty around the macro, but does the mid-single-digit expense growth tie into a mid-single-digit revenue growth or high single-digit revenue growth? Just talk to us how you’re thinking about that and if the revenue environment is worse, can that mid-single-digit expense growth go lower? Thanks.

Hratch Panossian: Yes. Thank you. Thank you for the question, Ebrahim, as I said in my remarks, there is uncertainty with respect to 2023. In terms of our long-term strategy and our results through €˜25 and our Investor Day targets, we feel very confident that we will deliver that high single-digit growth to the bottom line and positive operating leverage and strong ROE. €˜23 specifically, as I said in my remarks, the guidance is more to continue revenue growth, but we expect that to moderate from this year’s 9% level. We didn’t provide specific guidance, is that mid-single digits, is that mid- to high single digits because of the fact that there is uncertainty in the environment. What we are confident of is we will continue growth with our clients across all of our segments.

We will continue to gain share. We continue to have the benefits from interest rates as tailwinds, and we will stabilize expenses around this quarter’s levels, which will result in a full year year-over-year expense of around mid-single digits. And that is something that we’re very focused on. The revenue side can move around, depends on markets and fee revenues derived from that. there is lots of uncertainty. So between mid-single digits or a little less, a little more, I wouldn’t forecast that at this point or guide to it, Ebrahim. If things do get more uncertain, as we have done this quarter, you can rely on us to continue to manage to deliver our targets and continue to take actions to reposition the business and to try to deliver positive operating leverage over time, which is always our target.

Ebrahim Poonawala: But any strong views you have on operating leverage in €˜23.

Hratch Panossian: Sorry. I didn’t

Ebrahim Poonawala: I was just asking any strong views around hitting positive operating leverage in €˜23.

Hratch Panossian: Yes. As I said, we are confident we will deliver an aggregate positive operating leverage over the period of a few years. We’ve taken the extra step in our annual report, you may have noticed or maybe not yet, to define more specifically what we mean by our medium-term targets. And so we do look at them through the cycle over a 3 to 5-year period. And so we feel very confident about that. In terms of 2023, as I said in my remarks, we’re looking for better operating leverage than this year. We’re looking for operating leverage that is improving over time, and we’re confident that we can do that. And as always, in any given year, we would prefer positive operating leverage. However, we know we can control the expense side, we know we have more levers we can pull on the expense side if we needed to. But the revenue side could make positive operating leverage challenging in any short period of time.

Ebrahim Poonawala: Okay, thank you.

Operator: Thank you. The following question is from Meny Grauman from Scotiabank. Please go ahead.