Why BlackRock, Inc. (BLK) Got Sued and What It Means for You

Page 1 of 2

Many Wall Street firms believe the way to get rich is by using other people’s money. Two pension funds think that’s exactly what BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE:BLK) is doing with the money they’ve invested in iShares ETFs, and rather than passively letting it happen, they’ve decided to take action to stop it.

In their lawsuit, which was filed about two weeks ago in federal court in Tennessee, the pension funds covering two local union groups from Nashville and Cincinnati made allegations against BlackRock and its iShares ETF division, naming BlackRock’s president and iShares’ chairman personally in the suit. Let’s take a closer look at the lawsuit and find out why these pension funds think that they deserve justice.

blackrock_logo_2218

Understanding securities lending
The rationale behind the lawsuit deals primarily with the proceeds that iShares ETFs get from securities lending. As I looked at last month, securities lending involves institutional investors like ETFs or pension funds taking the stocks, bonds, and other securities that they own and seeking borrowers who are willing to pay them to borrow securities. The borrower posts collateral and pays interest on the loan, generating small but significant amounts of additional income.

These small amounts of securities lending income add up to big money. For custodial giants Northern Trust Corporation (NASDAQ:NTRS) and The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation (NYSE:BK) , providing services related to securities lending is a major part of their overall business. With fund managers like iShares, however, the question becomes who’s truly entitled to the income that securities lending programs generate.

What’s at stake
In their lawsuit, the pension funds argue that iShares violated fiduciary duties to their shareholders by keeping too much of the revenue that securities lending generated. According to the suit, various entities controlled by BlackRock ended up collecting 40% of the overall proceeds from securities lending, fees that the suit claims were “grossly excessive,” characterizing the practice as “looting.”

The lawsuit’s claims are fairly consistent with the findings of previous looks at iShares practices. IndexUniverse found last year that iShares kept about 35% of securities lending proceeds for its own account, which was a reduction from past practices closer to a 50-50 split a few years ago. All told, BlackRock earned nearly $400 million from securities lending fees in 2011.

For its part, BlackRock argues that the lawsuit is “without merit” and plans to fight it “vigorously.”

Vote with your feet
Lawsuits are useful for captive investors who don’t have choices about where to invest their money. For workers whose pension plans or 401(k) providers choose iShares ETFs exclusively, their only recourse is to fight back in the courts.

But if you have the latitude to choose your own ETF providers, you may find more equitable splits of securities lending revenue among iShares’ competitors. According to The Wall Street JournalState Street Corporation (NYSE:STT) keeps just 15% of the revenue it generates from securities lending, while Vanguard doesn’t retain anything, returning all the proceeds to its participating funds.

Page 1 of 2
Comments
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy

Insider Monkey beat the market by 52 percentage points in 24 months. Our beta is only 1.2 (don't click this link if beating the market isn't important to you).

Lists

The Best B-Boy Movies

Most Awesome Hip Hop Documentaries

Foods That Stain Your Teeth

Richest Doctors in the World

The Best Movie Sountracks Ever

The Highest Grossing Musicals on Broadway

The Most Successful Reality TV Stars

Cheapest Cities to Visit in the US

Most Expensive Summer Camps

Most Expensive Animals in the World

Most Expensive Specialty Crops in the World

Movies That Took Ages to Make

The Longest Hollywood Films Ever Made

Most Expensive Concert Stages

The Richest Bands of all Time

10 Most Corrupt Countries 2013 List

10 Countries with the Highest Quality of Life Index

Most Expensive Mattresses in the World

5 Smallest Countries by Land Area

The Ultimate Heartbreak Songs

Richest Teenagers in the World

10 Most Haunted Places in America

10 Best Places to Retire in Florida East Coast

Top 10 Places to See Before You Die

Top 8 Countries in the World Where Justice Prevails

10 Richest States in America

15 Wealthiest Countries in the World

Richest Singers in the World

Most Expensive Tasting Menu in New York City

Most Expensive Baby Items in the World

Most Expensive Hotel Suites in Vegas

Most Expensive Brunch in New York City

Most Expensive Beef Cuts in the World

25 Best Colleges to Get a Job

Top 10 US Supermarkets

The 25 Most Dangerous Cities in the World to Visit

Most Expensive Xbox Games

Top 11 Cities Where Billionaires Live

Top 10 Most Charitable Companies in America

Most Expensive Seafood in the World

The 10 Wildest Conspiracy Theories

The 10 Best Job Markets in the US

Top 10 Accounting Scandals of All Time

The 25 Biggest Cities in the World

Top 10 Best Paying Virtual Jobs

Most Expensive Leather Shoes in the World

Top 6 Things to Buy in March

The 10 Most Stressful Jobs in America – 2014 List

Top 10 Jobs for Introverted People

Top 10 Honeymoon Destinations in the World

Subscribe

Enter your email:

Delivered by FeedBurner

X

Thanks! An email with instructions is sent to !

Your email already exists in our database. Click here to go to your subscriptions

Insider Monkey returned 47.6% in its first year! Wondering How?

Download a complete edition of our newsletter for free!