The Progressive Corporation (PGR), The Allstate Corporation (ALL), Travelers Companies Inc (TRV) – Auto Insurers: Does Pricing “Discrimination” Pay?

Page 1 of 2

The Allstate Corporation (NYSE:ALL)The Consumer Federation of America recently released a report condemning some insurance companies, such as The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR), for using education level and occupation to set rates for auto coverage, while commending others, such as The Allstate Corporation (NYSE:ALL) and Travelers Companies Inc (NYSE:TRV), for not using these factors.

The CFA calls the practice “discriminatory,” while others view it as adept underwriting. Judgments aside, I wondered: Is there a difference in performance between the insurers that use these factors in underwriting and those that don’t?

The CFA study

According to a CNBC article:

CFA went online to get price quotes for two hypothetical customers: a factory worker with a high school diploma and a plant supervisor with a college degree.

Both were the same in every other way: a 30-year old single woman who rents in a moderate-income neighborhood, drives a 2003 Honda Civic, had no accidents or moving violations in the last 10 years and who went without insurance coverage for the past 15 days.

The price-shopping … attempts to get quotes from the 10 largest insurance companies for the minimum required liability coverage in 10 major urban areas …

Based on its analysis of the country’s top 10 insurance companies, CFA found price quotes that were as much as 40 percent higher for drivers with less education and lower-job status.

Insurance companies that used these factors in pricing:

American Family Insurance — private company

Liberty Mutual – private company

Geico — owned by Berkshire Hathaway

Progressive – public company

Farmers Insurance – owned by Zurich Insurance

Insurance companies that did not use these factors in pricing:

Allstate — public company

State Farm Insurance – private company

Travelers – public company

USAA — private

Stock price performances

There are only two public companies in each category, so this is hardly a statistically significant study. (I’m not including Berkshire Hathaway, as Geico is just one of many holdings. Also, keep in mind Farmers Insurance is just one of Zurich’s holdings.) Additionally, the companies have different business mixes. A more exact study would compare only auto loss ratios.

1-year advantage: non-”discriminators”

The Allstate Corporation (NYSE:ALL), by far, was the top performer. Travelers Companies Inc (NYSE:TRV), the other company that didn’t consider education and occupation in pricing decisions, came in the middle of the pack, roughly tied with The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR).

YCharts

5-year advantage: n/a

One might give the advantage to the companies that didn’t use the personal factors because one of them, Travelers Companies Inc (NYSE:TRV), is a runaway winner. However, that fact is muted by the others’ performances.

YCharts

Page 1 of 2
blog comments powered by Disqus
Insider Monkey Headlines
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy

Insider Monkey beat the market by 52 percentage points in 24 months Click to see monthly returns in table format!

Lists

The 10 Most Technologically Advanced Countries in the World

The 10 Safest Countries in the World to Live in Peace

The 10 Top Selling Smartphones in the World 2014

The 12 Biggest Shopping Centers in the World

The 10 Friendliest Countries in the World

Qihoo 360 Technology Co Ltd (QIHU), Actavis plc (ACT), Yahoo! Inc. (YHOO) Among 20 Long Ideas from Sohn Canada

The 10 Laziest Countries in the World

The 10 Most Polluted Countries in the World

The 10 Most Dangerous Cities in America 2014

The Top 10 Gold Producing Countries in the World

The 10 Tallest Buildings in the World

The 10 Richest Stand Up Comedians in the World

The 10 Fattest Countries in the World

The 5 Best Summer Jobs for Teens

The 10 Most Religious Countries in the World Keeping the Faith

The 10 Most Educated Countries in the World

The 10 Most Popular Cell Phones in the World

The 10 Drunkest Countries in the World

The 10 Most Expensive Private Schools in the World

The 10 Smallest Countries in the World

Walking Dead Season 5 Spoilers You’ll Wish You Didn’t Know

The 10 Poorest Countries in the World

The 10 Greenest Countries in the World

The Top 10 Countries with the Highest Population in the World

The 10 Most Visited Countries in the World

The Top 10 Star Wars Characters in the Iconic Series

The 10 Most Expensive Android Phones in the World

5 Reasons Why The Illuminati Is Real and a Threat to Society

The 6 Scariest Halloween Costumes Ever Screamed At

The 4 Biggest Hedge Fund Managers in the World Today

The 15 Most Densely Populated Countries in the World

The 10 Biggest Tea Drinking Countries in the World

Top 6 Ways to Improve Your Checkout Process and Close Sales

The 5 Most Profitable Online Businesses You Can Start Today

The 20 Most Profitable Hospitals in the US

The 5 Most Profitable Home Businesses to Start

The 7 Teams that Will Win the Stanley Cup in 2015

The Top 10 Most Expensive Digital Cameras to Snap Stunning Shots With

The 10 Highest Quality Fast Food Restaurants In America Today

The 8 Best Halloween Decorating Ideas to Spook Up Your House

10 Marvel Women that Should Get a Movie Right Now

The 20 Best Remixes of Popular Songs that Will Make You Forget the Originals

7 Most Expensive Cities in the World

5 Least Expensive Cities in the World

10 Celebrities Who Believe In Scientology

10 High Margin Food Products to Build a Business Around

The 10 Most Expensive Clothing Stores in the United States to Get Decked Out At

The 5 Biggest Kickstarter Scams That Swindled Backers’ Donations

The 10 Most Expensive Boarding Schools In the World

50 Crazy Facts About Japan You Won’t Believe

Subscribe

Enter your email:

Delivered by FeedBurner

X

Thanks! An email with instructions is sent to !

Your email already exists in our database. Click here to go to your subscriptions

Insider Monkey returned 47.6% in its first year! Wondering How?

Download a complete edition of our newsletter for free!