The ultra-luxury market has been a strong performer in recent years. As companies such as Michael Kors Holdings Ltd (NYSE:KORS) and Coach, Inc. (NYSE:COH) have expanded their product lines and focused on Asian operations, the stocks have attracted a plethora of investors, with the former up more than 130% in two years. One segment that tends to be neglected among analysts, though, is the art world. There are two major players in big art auctions — Sothebys (NYSE:BID) and Christie’s. Let’s look at the publicly traded option to see how it compares with other luxury stocks.
Investors seemingly haven’t been too interested in the big auction houses since the financial crisis because the art market has been relatively weak. Whether the market is coming back or not is up for debate, with some analysts saying we are at a natural turnaround point, while others forecast remaining tepidity. I am inclined to agree with the former, as the economy picks up overall and ultra-high-net-worth individuals increase their big spending. Additionally, the rapid ascent of wealthy Chinese will continue to spur the art market in the next several years.
That said, I love the art business. The auction houses make up to 20% commissions on the pieces sold, which can often be in the tens of millions. Margins are high, the clientele is fiercely loyal, and the industry is essentially a duopoly. If you’re trying to find businesses that meet Warren Buffett’s criteria of high moats and abundant cash flow, this is starting to like a good bet. Most importantly, the market seems to value Sotheby’s at single-digit or nearly flat growth in the coming year. This looks to be in contradiction with recent data.
Invest in the arts
According to a report from Deloitte, assets in art investment funds rose nearly 70% last year. This boded well for this year’s big auctions, such as Sotheby’s Impressionist and Modern Art Sale — one of the biggest of the year. The event brought in more than $300 million and points to year-over-year gains of 30%, according to company management. Will the trend continue throughout 2013? It’s hard to say, but these early-year auctions could be attractive indicators for the rest of the year’s events.
Perhaps the most important number of all, though, is where Sotheby’s fits in with other luxury stocks. Analyst estimates, tepid (and possibly incorrect) as they are, give a forward P/E of 14.3. Michael Kors Holdings Ltd (NYSE:KORS) trades at nearly 24 times earnings, while Tiffany & Co. (NYSE:TIF) trades at more than 18 times earnings. Sure, these aren’t identical businesses across the board, but the luxury segment tends to attract similar valuations.