A federal appeals court declined to enforce most of a National Labor Relations Board ruling that Starbucks Corporation (NASDAQ:SBUX) illegally threatened employees with reprisals for trying to unionize and pretended to surveil organizing efforts, Reuters reported on September 4.
In a 2-0 decision, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected claims that a Wichita, Kansas store manager and assistant manager broke federal labor law when they told employees the store had closed its hiring portal and cut hours because of union activity. Circuit Judge Stephen Higginson found these statements were not “threats of reprisal.” The court did uphold a finding that Starbucks illegally threatened to deny maternity leave benefits to a pregnant employee if workers unionized.
The ruling came two days after a separate federal appeals court in Manhattan reversed an NLRB finding that Starbucks illegally barred workers at a Meatpacking District store from wearing multiple pins or T-shirts supporting a union. The court said the board failed to balance the firm’s brand image interests against employee organizing rights. Employees at more than 700 Starbucks stores have voted to unionize and have filed hundreds of complaints with the NLRB against the company.
Bull Case
Two favorable appellate rulings in quick succession give Starbucks Corporation (NASDAQ:SBUX) meaningful legal relief. The 5th Circuit narrowed the NLRB’s case against the company. The 2nd Circuit separately reversed the dress-code ruling. Together, the decisions reduce some of the legal and reputational pressure surrounding Starbucks’ handling of unionization efforts.
Starbucks’ operational turnaround also keeps on gaining momentum. Fiscal third-quarter global comparable sales rose 7.9%, while adjusted earnings per share of $0.85 beat estimates by roughly 31%. Management also raised full-year EPS guidance to $2.55 to $2.65 from $2.25 to $2.45. It gives investors stronger evidence that Brian Niccol’s “Back to Starbucks” strategy can improve financial performance.
The turnaround has also started to improve Starbucks’ profitability. Non-GAAP operating margin expanded 430 basis points to 14.4%, marking a second consecutive quarter of margin growth. Initiatives such as the Green Apron staffing model have helped fuel both higher transaction volumes and larger average tickets. It shows Starbucks can improve store productivity alongside sales.
Bear Case
The court’s decision to uphold one finding still creates a significant legal and reputational risk. The court confirmed that Starbucks Corporation (NASDAQ:SBUX) illegally threatened to cut a pregnant employee’s maternity benefits over unionization. It gives critics a specific example of alleged anti-union conduct despite the broader narrowing of the NLRB’s case.
Starbucks keeps on facing a large and unresolved unionization movement. More than 700 stores have voted to unionize, while employees have filed hundreds of NLRB complaints. Hence, individual court victories do not resolve the broader labor challenge, which could create legal costs, operational distractions, and reputational pressure.
Starbucks still needs to convert its profitability gains into stronger top-line growth. Revenue declined 1% year over year during the quarter despite strong margin and earnings growth. The China restructuring also reduces Starbucks’ consolidated store base. It leaves the firm more dependent on North American performance to sustain overall revenue growth.
Hedge Fund Data
Insider Monkey’s database shows Starbucks Corporation (NASDAQ:SBUX) was held by 64 hedge funds in the second quarter of 2026, roughly flat from 65 in the first quarter, with holdings value rising to $2.63 billion from $1.98 billion. McDonald’s, a comparable quick-service rival, saw its fund count fall to 79 from 83, with holdings value declining to $4.01 billion from $4.96 billion. Starbucks’ rising dollar value against a flat fund count contrasts with McDonald’s decline on both measures this quarter.
Conclusion
Starbucks has strengthened its outlook as Niccol’s turnaround produces measurable gains in sales, margins, and earnings. Recent court rulings provide some legal relief. However, the company still faces a major labor dispute, a damaging finding that survived the appeal, and weaker revenue growth that leaves it more dependent on North America.
Starbucks now needs to show that its operational improvements can turn into long-term revenue growth while it manages its labor challenges, making the durability of the turnaround the key factor for investors to watch.
READ NEXT: CrowdStrike (CRWD)’s CEO Warns AI Is Exposing Gaps in Legacy Cybersecurity Tools and Salesforce (CRM)’s AI Numbers Just Gave Benioff His Swagger Back.
Hedge Fund Resource Center