BJ’s Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:BJ) is the warehouse club nobody argues about. Costco gets the attention, and Sam’s Club has Walmart behind it.
Moody’s has just moved its outlook on BJ’s to positive from stable, affirming a Ba1 rating and pointing to a possible move into investment grade. The shares rose 2.12%. The interesting part is not the rating. It is what BJ’s costs relative to the company it is copying.
READ ALSO: BJ’s Wholesale Club (BJ) Formalizes Investment-Grade Financial Policy
The Same Model, Growing Faster, at Less Than Half the Price:
A warehouse club does not really sell groceries. It sells an annual membership and then keeps prices low enough that renewing feels automatic.
Those fees arrive before any product moves and cost almost nothing to service, which is why they fall almost entirely to profit. It is the most attractive structure in retail, and BJ’s runs it.
What separates BJ’s is the price of admission. The shares change hands near twenty times earnings. Costco trades near forty-five times. That is not a small gap for two companies operating the same machine.
Growth does not explain the discount either. BJ’s grew revenue about 16% in its most recent quarter, which is a rate the far larger clubs cannot match on a base that size.
Moody’s is pointing at the same thing from a different angle. The agency highlighted a balanced financial policy, leverage kept deliberately low, and ample undrawn liquidity on its revolving facility. A retailer moving toward investment grade while growing at this rate is not the profile of a struggling business.
DON’T MISS: Jim Cramer Says Costco (COST) “Stock’s Acting Poorly”
Small, Regional and Standing Between Two Giants:
The discount exists for reasons, and the main one is size.
BJ’s is worth around $11 billion. Costco is worth many multiples of that, and Walmart considerably more again. Both competitors can absorb price investment for longer than BJ’s can survive matching it, and both have been doing exactly that.
Geography compounds it. BJ’s is concentrated along the eastern United States rather than spread nationally, which limits how much scale it can build in purchasing and how quickly it can open new clubs without cannibalizing existing ones.
The margins show the strain. BJ’s earns a net margin near 2.6%, which leaves very little room for error if club competition sharpens. Sam’s Club has been growing its own membership income at a double-digit pace, so the larger players are not standing still.
Conclusion:
BJ’s runs the best model in retail and is growing revenue faster than the clubs it competes with. Moody’s is pushing it toward investment grade while citing exactly the qualities that make the model work. It trades near twenty times earnings while Costco commands forty-five. That gap is wider than the growth rates justify. It is a smaller, more regional operator with thin margins, squeezed between two companies that can outspend it indefinitely, and those are real constraints rather than excuses. Size and geography are real limits, but they are stable limits rather than worsening ones, and the discount prices them as though they were getting worse.
On balance, BJ’s is a good investment at this price. The number to watch is whether revenue growth holds in the mid teens, because that is what separates it from the clubs it trades at a discount to.
Market Sentiment:
BJ’s Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. was held by 40 hedge funds with a combined stake value of about $0.9 billion at the end of Q2 2026 in the Insider Monkey database. This is up from 35 hedge fund holders with a cumulative investment value of around $0.5 billion in the previous quarter.
READ NEXT: Visa (V) vs American Express (AXP): Which is a Better Stock to Buy and Twilio (TWLO) Keeps Climbing as Investors Rediscover its AI Business
This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
Hedge Fund Resource Center