All revolutionary, game-changer, disruptive, first-mover technologies have their nay-sayers. The personal computer and motorcar were considered a rich man’s toy much as the electric vehicle made by Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) has been.
Unsurprisingly, there is an academic psychology analysis tool, called the Technology Acceptance Model, that explains the stages of acceptance of new technology. Basically, it is perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness that factor into a human decision to adopt new technology, with newer variants of the model factoring in social influence and facilitating conditions. The model has been tested on smartphone adoption, social media, and other technology with a 70% success rate.
What does this mean?
A better example may be how long it took cars made by Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) to gain acceptance. The Model T was the first truly mass-market car and so wildly popular it moved a nation of horseback riders to become drivers. Henry Ford dropped the price from $1,000 to its eventual $365 to get those cars moving. According to Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) CEO Elon Musk, an affordable model, the Gen III, could be rolled out as early as 2016.
Perceived usefulness of the Tesla is the main issue. Is how much a driver saves on fossil fuel and the inconvenience of charging the car worth the sticker price? In other words, “range anxiety.”
Investors should be encouraged by news of Kroger supermarkets’ and Walgreen drugstores’ installation of EV charging stations, as well as news reports that the Pennsylvania Turnpike will have four EV stations installed this summer with fast chargers at all service plazas over time. At charging costs of $2-$5 it is certainly cheaper than a fillup. Walgreens expects 40% of drivers will charge their EVs at Walgreens soon.
Perceived ease of use is crucial. For 10 years Tesla has been improving their vehicle and powertrain components until the car offers the same driving experience as a standard car. The Tesla Model S was named 2013 Car of the Year By Automobile and Motor Trend. The Automobile testing editors described it akin to using an iPhone with its intuitive experience.
Test editors noted the Nissan Leaf and other models like the Chevy Volt and the Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F)Focus electric come nowhere close to driving like a regular car. This explains why Tesla has outsold those models and reported a profit for the first time this year.
This is fairly similar to the way the Model T gained traction and became the most popular car in America. The Model S is already the US’ most popular electric car, outselling the Volt by 329 cars in the first quarter despite the Volt’s lower sticker price.
This has brought down Tesla’s valuation to a forward P/E of 40.93 and closing at an all-time high of $54.96 on April 29. Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) should also gain from the demise of electric car rival Fisker Automotive, just as Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) did as rivals dropped away in the early 1900s.
Taking a page from the Apple playbook, Teslas are sold only in boutiques owned by Tesla, not run of the mill auto dealerships. On this, Tesla is facing some headwinds as various state regulations prohibit direct-to-consumer sales of autos (48 states) and as expected, old-school dealerships are vigorously opposing any change to those rules. It may come to the point of a future Capraesque film, Mr. Musk Goes To Washington.
What Henry Ford did with the Model T was make it affordable and that is the big challenge for Tesla; to take Silicon Valley technology and the assembly line and parts innovations made by Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) a century ago and make the affordable EV that will be not just the ticket to freedom that the Model T represented but the ticket to fossil fuel freedom.
The Model T catalyzed the building of the interstate highway system. EVs already have governmental and state support (especially in California, big surprise) in the form of carpool lanes and federal tax credits for buyers, up to $7,500.
Lee Iacocca saved General Motors Company (NYSE:GM) by offering warranties longer than usual to instill confidence for an American consumer tired of the poor quality of US craftsmanship. Likewise, Musk is offering an eight-year warranty on the battery as well as loaner cars and the opportunity to upgrade to that loaner car.
Are all EV companies created equal?
Tesla wins the tecnology acceptance model race on perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness by its better quality and competitveness with similar class models. It’s also winning on the somewhat intangible social influence front with Silicon Valley and Hollywood adherents, Ed Begley Jr. aside.
The Ford Focus electric vehicle is cheaper than a Tesla but pricey for a sedan at $39,200, compared to its own Ford Focus standard internal combustion car at $16,200. And it can only go up to 76 miles on a single charge.
The Volt is priced competitively to the Focus electric. But General Motors Company (NYSE:GM) may have the head start on Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) with a Cadillac electric vehicle coming soon, which should definitely appeal to those with the wherewithal to buy a Model S.
Toyota Motor Corporation (ADR) (NYSE:TM) has stepped aside to see how it shakes out. It is only making one fully electric car, its RAV4, in cooperation with Tesla. Its hybrid Prius is doing so well it can afford (temporarily) to stay out of the fray.
The Foolish driveaway
While Tesla has first mover advantage the challenge remains getting that Gen III car for the common man available before Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F), General Motors Company (NYSE:GM), or Toyota Motor Corporation (ADR) (NYSE:TM) with their economies of scale make their own versions of an electric Model T. The infrastructure is falling into place and demand is there. Tesla just needs to ratchet up production and cut the price.
TSLA Total Return Price data by YCharts
AnnaLisa Kraft has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Ford, General Motors, and Tesla Motors. The Motley Fool owns shares of Ford and Tesla Motors.
The article Is the Model S Like the Model T? originally appeared on Fool.com.
Copyright © 1995 – 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
