General Motors Company (GM), Ford Motor Company (F): King Of The Hill

It would make sense that in the most profitable vehicle segment — full-size pickups — you would find the most heated rivalry. That certainly holds true between America’s two largest automakers, Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) and General Motors Company (NYSE:GM). In the world of trucks you’re either a Ford or a Chevy guy, and that’s that — there’s no switching sides or gray area. The rivalry is stuff of legends, and while Ford has been dominating truck sales since the recession, GM now has one thing it can tout over its crosstown rival, at least for now: its No. 1 safety rating. Will that help the Silverado in its push to finally top the F-Series for the best-selling truck?

I doubt it. Here’s why.

King of the hill

If you’ve been keeping track, the F-Series has been America’s best-selling truck for 31 years now. The Silverado has had second place locked down but can’t gain any ground on the F-Series.


Graph by author; 0information from Automotive News Data Center. 2013 projected from sales through July.

Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F)’s F-Series has even widened the sales gap since the recession, because some consumers refuse to buy from General Motors Company (NYSE:GM) after its taxpayer-fueled bailout. GM loyalists often point out that if you combine all of GM’s full-size sales, between the Silverado and Sierra, they do outsell Ford — but that hasn’t been true recently.


Graph by author; information from Autmotive News DataCenter. 2013 projected from sales through July.

Once again, since the recession Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) has widened the sales gap even when you combine Silverado and Sierra sales. Right now General Motors Company (NYSE:GM) is pushing back, with both of its trucks receiving complete redesigns for the 2014 model, while the next-generation F-150 is a year away. This may be GM’s small window of opportunity to gain ground, and sales for the Silverado and Sierra have surged 45% and 49%, respectively, for July as the new designs hit showrooms across the nation.

To follow up a great sales performance in July, the 2014 Silverado and Sierra just received a five-star overall safety rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Those two are the first full-size pickups to get the highest safety rating possible since the tougher judging system was implemented three years ago.

“Silverado and Sierra set a benchmark for pickup truck safety by offering a full array of advanced features designed to protect occupants before, during, and after a collision,” Gay Kent, General Motors Company (NYSE:GM) general director of vehicle safety and crashworthiness, said in a statement, according to Automotive News.

Why it doesn’t matter

Even though Silverado and Sierra sales are surging, I don’t believe its No. 1 safety rank will be enough to win back the sales crown this year — in part because only 14% of consumers rank safety as their top priority when purchasing a vehicle.


Graph by authorl information from Consumer Reports.

Another reason I don’t think the Silverado will top the F-Series is that the truck segment is insanely loyal. Moreover, Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) is No. 1 in brand loyalty, according to an R.L. Polk survey. Even the less loyal consumers that remain on the fence about making a purchase may opt to wait for the next-generation F-150 — and if it looks anything like the Atlas concept, it’s going to draw major attention.