On August 25, DICK’S Sporting Goods (NYSE:DKS) reported second-quarter results that told two very different stories under one roof. Consolidated net sales jumped 53.2% to $5.59 billion, but nearly all of that growth came from the newly acquired Foot Locker business rather than organic strength. The company’s core DICK’S banner kept humming along with a 4.9% comp sales gain, even as Foot Locker’s comparable sales fell 3.6% and full-year earnings guidance was slashed. The quarter made clear that folding Foot Locker into the business is proving costlier and slower than expected.
The Core Business Keeps Delivering
DICK’S core operations grew comp sales 4.9% in the quarter, split between a 3.6% rise in average ticket and a 1.3% increase in transactions, with broad-based growth across footwear, apparel and hardlines. That comp growth outpaced the broader industry by nearly 200 basis points. Gross margin for the DICK’S business actually expanded 79 basis points, a notable feat given how promotional the marketplace became, and management credited that expansion to growth in the DICK’S Media Network and the GameChanger youth sports platform. Those two businesses are increasingly diversifying earnings away from pure merchandise sales.
The company also kept investing in its experiential store formats, opening five House of Sport and eight Field House locations during the quarter and landing prime real estate in markets like Cerritos, Tysons Corner and Palm Beach Gardens. On the loyalty side, DICK’S relaunched its ScoreCard program and introduced ScoreCard+, a paid tier priced at $99 per year aimed at its most engaged shoppers within a base of roughly 30 million active athletes. The balance sheet backs up all of this activity, with $914 million in cash and zero borrowings against a $2 billion credit facility.
A Costly Bet Turns Heavy
The Foot Locker acquisition is where the quarter turned rough. Pro forma comparable sales for Foot Locker fell 3.6%, hurt by weak demand for legacy athletic footwear silhouettes and launch products that underperformed expectations. Management now expects that promotional pressure to persist at least through the fourth quarter, and the EMEA business has been especially difficult. Executives pointed to excess industry inventory and a consumer that has grown more cautious than expected due to the geopolitical environment there. The financial toll shows up across the consolidated numbers. Gross margin fell 300 basis points to 34.1%, largely a mix effect from adding the lower-margin Foot Locker business, while consolidated operating margin dropped to 8.1% from 13.02% a year ago. SG&A expenses rose $562 million, with $477 million tied directly to the Foot Locker addition.
Earnings per share came in at $3.53, down from $4.38 last year, weighed down further by the dilutive impact of 9.6 million shares issued for the deal. Integration charges have already reached $516 million of an expected $750 million total, and the company raised its full-year tax rate guidance to 29%. Full-year EPS guidance was cut sharply, to $11 to $12 from a prior range of $13.50 to $14.50.
Investors Split On What Comes Next
Hedge fund ownership of DICK’S rose from 48 funds to 52 funds in the most recent quarter, suggesting institutional buyers have been adding rather than exiting the name even as guidance came down. Short interest sits at 12.54% of float, a level that points to a sizable bear camp already positioned against the stock. Yet the forward price-to-earnings ratio of just 9.54 as of September 1 suggests that the market has priced in relatively little future growth.
Two Businesses, One Uncertain Path
DICK’S enters the back half of the year as two businesses moving in opposite directions. The core banner keeps gaining share and expanding margin even in a tough marketplace, while Foot Locker’s turnaround has been pushed further out by inventory gluts and softer footwear demand. For the bulls, continued comp growth, media and loyalty monetization, and reaffirmed cost synergy targets of $100 million to $125 million would need to keep offsetting the drag.
READ NEXT: 10 Best Future Stocks to Buy Under $10 and 12 Best Performing Semiconductor Stocks to Invest In.
Disclosure: None. Follow Insider Monkey on Google News.
