In this article, we will list the 5 Best Insurance Stocks to Buy Right Now. Please visit 11 Best Insurance Stocks to Buy Right Now if you’d like to see an extended list and how we came up with the list of best insurance stocks.
5. MetLife Inc. (NYSE:MET)
MetLife Inc. (NYSE:MET) is one of the 11 best insurance stocks to buy right now.
On March 10, MetLife Inc. (NYSE:MET) stated that it had been informed of Potemkin’s unsolicited mini-tender offer to buy up to 10,000 shares of MetLife’s common stock from its existing shareholders. This represents approximately 0.002% of the total outstanding shares of MetLife as of February 12.
The closing price of MetLife’s common stock, which was $70.77 as of March 9, is nearly 27.09% more than the price of $51.60 per share that Potemkin is offering. Since the price being offered by Potemkin is less than the current market price of MetLife’s common stock, MetLife is not supporting Potemkin’s unsolicited mini-tender offer and is advising its shareholders not to take any steps with regard to it.
Adam Gregor/Shutterstock.com
Earlier on February 25, Elyse Greenspan from Wells Fargo reduced the firm’s price target on MetLife Inc. (NYSE:MET) from $97 to $93, still resulting in a potential upside of almost 35% at the prevailing level. The analyst maintained an Overweight rating on the stock.
MetLife Inc. (NYSE:MET) is a financial services company engaged in insurance, employee benefits, and asset management services worldwide. It offers benefits and retirement plans, and also manages protection plans and pension risk transfers. The company also delivers savings plans and annuity products, including fixed, indexed-linked, and variable.
4. Slide Insurance Holdings Inc. (NASDAQ:SLDE)
Slide Insurance Holdings Inc. (NASDAQ:SLDE) is one of the 11 best insurance stocks to buy right now.
On March 9, Keefe Bruyette increased the price target for Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:SLDE) from $22 to $23. The firm reaffirmed its Outperform rating on the stock, which results in an adjusted upside of more than 27%. The revision came at the back of what the firm described as a “strong” fourth quarter for the company.
On February 26, Piper Sandler analyst Paul Newsome increased the firm’s price target on Slide Insurance Holdings Inc. (NASDAQ:SLDE) from $22 to $24, which leads to an adjusted upside potential of almost 33%. The analyst maintained an Overweight rating on the shares following its quarterly results, where topline growth came in ahead of both its expectations and consensus estimates.
Looking ahead, guidance for 2026 also exceeded forecasts, with stronger outlooks for both revenue and earnings. The analyst added that the company delivered a solid quarter overall, reinforcing confidence in its near-term growth trajectory.
Slide Insurance Holdings Inc. (NASDAQ:SLDE) is a tech-enabled insurance company that leverages big data and AI capabilities to offer personalized insurance solutions to customers. Keeping the unique needs and circumstances of individuals in mind, they deliver insurance plans for homeowners, commercial, residential properties, and condominiums.
3. Ryan Specialty Holdings Inc. (NYSE:RYAN)
Ryan Specialty Holdings Inc. (NYSE:RYAN) is one of the 11 best insurance stocks to buy right now.
On February 27, Mizuho reduced its price target on Ryan Specialty Holdings Inc. (NYSE:RYAN) to $44 from $53. The firm reiterated its Neutral rating on the stock, which still offers a revised upside of almost 22% despite the downward adjustment.
The adjustment is based on the firm’s revisions to its targets and ratings across the insurance property and casualty segment, amid the recent selloff witnessed within the sector.
Earlier on February 25, BMO Capital analyst Michael Zaremski downgraded Ryan Specialty Holdings Inc. (NYSE:RYAN) from Outperform to Market Perform. The analyst also lowered his price target from $66 to $43.
Zaremski believes that the excess and surplus insurance market, where Ryan primarily operates, is likely to see a material growth deceleration through 2027. Reflecting on this outlook, he reduced estimates, citing expectations for slower organic growth, weaker margins, and lower contribution from acquisitions, which could weigh on the company’s overall earnings trajectory and limit upside potential in the near to medium term.
Ryan Specialty Holdings Inc. (NYSE:RYAN) operates as a service provider of specialty products and solutions for insurance brokers, agents, and carriers. It delivers various services such as distribution, underwriting, product development, and risk management. The company serves different commercial and private market segments.
2. The Baldwin Insurance Group Inc. (NASDAQ:BWIN)
The Baldwin Insurance Group Inc. (NASDAQ:BWIN) is one of the 11 best insurance stocks to buy right now.
On March 9, UBS reduced the firm’s price target on The Baldwin Insurance Group Inc. (NASDAQ:BWIN) from $44 to $40. The firm reiterated its Buy rating on the stock, which still yields an adjusted upside potential of close to 90%.
Back on February 27, Raymond James upgraded The Baldwin Insurance Group Inc. (NASDAQ:BWIN) from an Outperform rating to Strong Buy. The firm also increased its price target from $20 to $30 on the shares, which results in a revised upside of more than 42%.
Raymond James noted that the stock has declined about 23% year-to-date, driven in part by AI-related concerns and near-term pressure on organic revenue growth. Despite this, the firm sees the current valuation as compelling and believes Baldwin’s 2026 growth outlook remains strong. It also highlighted management’s view that share repurchases would be the best use of capital in the near term, given the stock’s current valuation.
The Baldwin Insurance Group Inc. (NASDAQ:BWIN) is an insurance distributor that provides insurance and risk management services. Some of its services include private and commercial risk management, health and personal insurance, and reinsurance. The company also offers an extensive range of technology-led insurance products.
1. Accelerant Holdings (NYSE:ARX)
Accelerant Holdings (NYSE:ARX) is one of the 11 best insurance stocks to buy right now.
Back on February 23, Paul Newsome from Piper Sandler reduced the price target on Accelerant Holdings (NYSE:ARX) from $18 to $13. The analyst maintained an Overweight rating on the stock, which currently yields almost 17% upside potential despite the downward revision.
On February 17, Raymond James analyst C. Gregory Peters reduced the price target on Accelerant Holdings (NYSE:ARX) to $13 from $21 while maintaining an Outperform rating. The fear of replacement by AI has led to a decline of around 22% so far this year for insurance brokers and insurance technology stocks.
Yet the analyst observed that stable credit spreads, interest rates, and management guidance suggest that there has been no underlying deterioration in fundamentals. Although multi-year investments in AI infrastructure and significant hyperscale capital expenditures support premium growth, organic growth and margin expansion may slow in 2026. Large-cap brokers are still well-positioned to outperform the market and could accelerate share repurchases if valuations remain compressed.
Accelerant Holdings (NYSE:ARX) is a data-led risk exchange that brings together specialty insurance underwriters and risk capital partners. It offers a platform to facilitate members and risk capital partners. The company also delivers underwriting services for insurance and reinsurance policies.
While we acknowledge the potential of ARX as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and have limited downside risk. If you are looking for an AI stock that is more promising than ARX and that has 100x upside potential, check out our report about the cheapest AI stock.
READ NEXT: 40 Most Popular Stocks Among Hedge Funds Heading Into 2026 and 12 Oversold Financial Stocks to Invest in According to Hedge Funds.
Disclosure: None. Insider Monkey focuses on uncovering the best investment ideas of hedge funds and insiders. Please subscribe to our free daily e-newsletter to get the latest investment ideas from hedge funds’ investor letters by entering your email address below.
