Millions of Americans lost tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars of net worth during the housing bust, as the value of their homes plunged. Yet as well-intentioned as government initiatives are in trying to address the financial impact of the mortgage crisis, the newest program to help struggling mortgage borrowers seems to encourage exactly the behavior you’d want homeowners to avoid.
More options for delinquent homeowners
On July 1, the Federal Housing Finance Agency’s Streamlined Modification Initiative (link opens PDF file) took effect. As FHFA Acting Director Edward DeMarco said back in March when the initiative was first announced, the “new option gives delinquent borrowers another path to avoid foreclosure.”
Under the program, eligible homeowners who are 90 days or more behind on their mortgage payments will automatically receive an offer that includes a reduced mortgage payment based on a fixed interest rate. Payment terms will be extended to 40 years, and for some of those who owe more on their loans than their homes are currently worth, the program will provide limited reductions of the amount of principal they owe on their mortgages.
The FHFA hopes that this program will succeed where others have failed. In particular, because the Streamlined Modification Initiative doesn’t require homeowners to complete an application or provide evidence of financial hardship, the agency is optimistic that more eligible homeowners will participate than have used similar programs in the past.
Will the FHFA catch strategic defaults?
The danger with the new program, though, is that it provides no incentives for homeowners who’ve kept current on their payments. Indeed, it arguably gives homeowners a reason to stop making mortgage payments in the hope that by doing so, they’ll become entitled to favorable benefits that wouldn’t otherwise be available to them.
Indeed, previous programs designed to help homeowners avoid foreclosure raised similar concerns about moral hazard. Back in 2009, the earliest attempts to provide for mortgage loan modifications resulted in far fewer benefits than expected, because the banks involved chose not to grant modification in many cases. Wells Fargo & Co (NYSE:WFC) and Bank of America Corp (NYSE:BAC) were among the slowest of the big banks to modify loans early in the program’s existence, moving forward with just 4% to 6% of eligible mortgages within the first half-year or so of the program. Even giving lenders incentives to modify loans didn’t keep bankers from concluding that they’d often be better off not modifying and counting on homeowners to find ways to cure their delinquent loans without a modification. In other words, banks chose not to reward their customers automatically for being late and seeking assistance.