Profit from Insider Sales by Short Selling: New Evidence

Monkeying insider purchases has been a very profitable investment strategy. Insiders usually own a lot of stocks and/or options in their companies. Increasing concentration of wealth in a single stock usually is not rational. Random events may strike the company and the investor might lose most of the wealth in a heartbeat (i.e. Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers insiders). So when insiders take the risk of buying more shares, usually it’s because they know something we don’t. That’s why imitating insider purchases is such a rewarding strategy.

On the other hand, selling is the rational thing to do for most insiders even when they think they expect slightly better results from their companies. The benefits of diversification compensate for the loss of future stock returns. Of course selling is the right thing to do when insiders are pessimistic about the future. As a result insider sales is much more common than insider purchases, but the act is much less informative. Insider sales have been intensifying during the past two decades as insiders receive increasing quantities of stock and option awards. There’s now a greater need to diversify compared to 10 or 20 years ago.

Academic research on insider sales has revealed that imitating all insider sales transactions is not profitable. It’s because most insider sales transactions are done for diversification or demand for liquidity. So, the lists of the largest insider sales published in the Wall Street Journal or Barron’s really don’t mean much.

However, it’s possible to get rid of the noise in insider sales transactions and develop a potentially profitable investment strategy. A 2009 research paper by Alan Jagolinzer (Stanford University) analyzed insider transactions conducted under the protection of Rule 10b5-1. The SEC enacted Rule 10b5-1 to protect insiders’ preplanned, non-information based trades from litigation. When Angelo Mozillo was selling his Countrywide shares in the millions, he was doing so under a 10b5-1 plan. Jagolinzer found that insiders participate in these plans preceding negative firm performance. A substantial proportion of plans were initiated before adverse news disclosures. Jagolinzer also found evidence of early terminations of the plans when there was pending positive firm performance.

Jagolinzer also calculated market adjusted buy and hold returns for stocks sold under 10b5-1 plans. These stocks underperform the market by 70 basis points for a 1-month holding period. The underperformance is 220 basis points for a 3-month horizon and 360 basis points for a 6-month horizon. Alternatively, this strategy’s alpha was calculated using Carhart’s four factor model. Insiders who participated in a 10b5-1 plan and sold their holdings had a monthly alpha of 70 basis points (t-stat=-2.28). That’s consistent with buy-and-hold abnormal returns. Insiders who didn’t participate in a 10b5-1 plan and sold their shares in the open market had a negative alpha of 50 basis points (t-stat=1.93) per month, meaning the stocks beat the market after the insiders sold them.

These are very promising results. The only drawback of Jagolinzer’s study is that it covers the 2000-2005 period, a relatively short period from which to draw a definitive conclusion. If the results held up during the post-2005 period, they could be used to create a very profitable short selling strategy.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Insider Monkey Headlines
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy

Insider Monkey beat the market by 52 percentage points in 24 months Click to see monthly returns in table format!

Lists

Top 20 Female Billionaires in 2014

6 Movies That You Should Watch to Better Understand The Cold War

Top 15 Best Paying Jobs for Women in 2014

Top 6 Things Rich People Do Differently Every Day

5 Retirement Mistakes To Avoid (and Einstein’s Famous Quote)

11 Smartest People in the World

6 Films About the Financial World You Need To Watch (While “The Wolf” is Not Around)

Warren Buffett and Billionaires Are Crazy About These 7 Stocks

The Top 10 States With Fastest Internet Speeds

10 Best Places to Visit in USA in August

Top 10 Cities to Visit Before You Die

Top 10 Genetically Modified Food In the US

15 Highest Grossing Movies Opening Weekend

5 Best Poker Books For Beginners

10 Strategies Hedge Funds Use to Make Huge Returns

Top 10 Fast Food Franchises to Buy

10 Best Places to Visit in Canada

Best Summer Jobs for Teachers

10 Youngest Hedge Fund Billionaires

Top 10 One Hit Wonders of the 90s

Fastest Growing Cities In America

Top 10 U.S. Cities for Freelancers

Top 9 Most Popular Free iPhone Apps

Top 10 Least Expensive Private Business Schools in the US

Top 15 Most Expensive Countries in the World – 2014

Top 6 Tax Scams and How to Protect Yourself

Top Businesses to Invest In

Top 5 Things You Might Be Doing Wrong With Your Business

Top 5 Strategic Technology Trends in 2014

Top Rags to Riches Stories

Parenting Behavior That Promotes Future Leaders

Top 5 Mistakes Made by Small Businesses

Top 5 Most Common and Potentially Devastating Financial Blunders

Top 5 Highest Paying Jobs for Web Designers

Top 6 Most Respected Professions that Also Pay Well

Top 5 Pitfalls Investors Should Avoid

Top 6 Lawyers and Policy Makers Under 30

Top 6 New Year’s Resolutions for Entrepreneurs

Top 7 Locations to Check in on Facebook

Top 5 Mistakes made by Rookie eBay Sellers

Top 7 eBook Publishers in 2013

Top 6 Health Industry Trends in 2014

5 Lessons for Entrepreneurs from Seth Godin

Top 5 Success Tips from Jordan Belfort – the Wolf of Wall Street

Best Master’s in Finance Degree Programs

Top 6 Earning Celebrities Over 50

The most expensive sports to play

Top 7 Earning Celebrities Under 25

Best 7 Online Courses to Take: Free Finance MOOCs

Top 6 Bad Habits that Promote Failure

Subscribe

Enter your email:

Delivered by FeedBurner

X

Thanks! An email with instructions is sent to !

Your email already exists in our database. Click here to go to your subscriptions

Insider Monkey returned 47.6% in its first year! Wondering How?

Download a complete edition of our newsletter for free!