Last year, Oracle Corporation (NASDAQ:ORCL) CEO Larry Ellison was awarded 7 million stock options, valued at $90.7 million, in the face of significant shareholder disapproval. Oracle’s board defended the decision by pointing out that the $90.7 million valuation isn’t necessarily an accurate measure of the compensation Ellison will receive.
The board is right to claim that the $90.7 million valuation of Ellison’s 2012 pay is misleading. In the end, Ellison’s 2012 pay will likely be significantly higher than the $90.7 reported in the company’s proxy — even if Oracle goes on to underperform.
Oracle points out that the options granted to Ellison had no intrinsic value when they were granted, and would only gain intrinsic value if the stock appreciates. That much is true. The strike price of options granted to Oracle’s named executive officers was based on the closing price of Oracle’s common stock on the date the options were granted, so the $90.7 million valuation was entirely based on the time value of the options, which are good for 10 years.
Also, these options take four years to fully vest. Four years from now, Ellison’s 2012 options will have less time value, so he’ll only be able to bank his $90.7 million if Oracle’s stock price appreciates under his leadership.
What the proxy doesn’t tell you
Even if we buy Oracle’s claim that intrinsic value is a better indicator of the “true value and worth” of Ellison’s options, a few basic calculations show us that Ellison doesn’t have to help Oracle put up a very strong performance to get his $90.7 million payday.
How much does Oracle’s stock price have to appreciate over the 10-year life span of Ellison’s 2012 options for him to get that $90.7 million? Only about 3.4% a year!
Guess how much Ellison’s 2012 options will be worth 10 years from now if Oracle’s share price doubles, offering average increases of 7% per year. About $227 million! That’s a heck of a lot of money to pay for share appreciation soundly beaten by the nearly 10% average historical annual growth put up by large-cap stocks on the whole. Granted, this average includes gains made through dividends, but with a yield lower than 1%, Ellison isn’t doing much for shareholders in that arena, either.