Get out of McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD) stock. It’s up more than 33% over the last two years. With info like that you might think this sizzling stock is worth owning. You would be wrong.
Improving customer satisfaction
McDonald’s has finally come to grips with the fact that people care about how they are treated. This was made painfully obvious in a recent meeting with franchisees where McDonald’s executives revealed that 20% of all customer complaints are related to “friendliness” issues.
Having recognized this problem, McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD) hopes to flip this perception. To do so they are not only informing franchisees of the issue, they are also rolling out a new nationwide program to increase friendliness and customer satisfaction.
Orders will now be taken in one area and picked up down the counter in another section. A new position called the “runner” has been created. This person distributes sauce, cups, happy meal toys, etc. This frees up the person taking orders from having to do this. The final person to hand the customer their meal is supposed to be friendly, thank the customer for coming, and ask them to come again.
This seems like a great step for McDonald’s. The company is focusing on customer needs and addressing a major customer concern. If effectively implemented, this new approach should resonate well with customers.
Back in October, McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD) posted its first sales decline in nine years and realized it was going down the wrong track. The company had been pushing its more expensive menu items, which took a bite out of sales.
Since then, the company has refocused its marketing and is once again stressing cheaper items such as those on its dollar menu. The new marketing campaign launched in January, and its full impact has yet to be seen.
A weak economy hurts business at all levels, even fast-food chains that sell cheap food. The economy is certainly to blame for McDonald’s failed attempt to push the more expensive menu items. It seems that McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD) was too hopeful regarding the average consumer, thinking they were ready for costlier items when they really weren’t.
While the Dow Jones industrial average might be setting record highs, consumer spending is not. A Gallup survey on consumer spending indicates that spending is still down about $20 per day from pre-recession levels.
Competitor copy cats
McDonald’s refocused its marketing strategy in order to stress value and it’s dollar-menu items. Competitors have caught on and are now bringing the same kind of message.
The Wendy’s Company (NASDAQ:WEN) has a new menu category known as “Right Price, Right Size.” These are items in the $1 to $2 range. Steve Hare, CFO of Wendy’s, was quoted as saying “this business is so competitive every year. But if possible, I think this year is even more (so).”
Fast-food companies have always competed on price and value, but this year even more so due to the fact that consumer spending has been slow to recover and people are looking to keep their expenses to a minimum. This added price competition will impact fast-food companies like Wendy’s and McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD) by driving down profits. As a result, this year’s quarterly earnings reports will likely be very disappointing for investors.
Burger King Worldwide Inc (NYSE:BKW) is also getting into the value competition. After sales declined in January, it lowered the price of its Whopper Jr. to get it closer to the $1.00 category. According to Burger King, sales have rebounded in March. This move is similar to what McDonald’s did earlier this year when it refocused its marketing around less-expensive items.
In Burger King’s case, though, it didn’t just refocus its marketing–the company lowered the price of one of its main items. This move endangers Burger King’s profitability going forward. While the company might have sold more Whoppers in March than in January, its profit per Whopper has gone down. Once again, it is a fast-food company that will likely see declining profits this year.
All three of these companies, McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE:MCD), The Wendy’s Company (NASDAQ:WEN) and Burger King Worldwide Inc (NYSE:BKW), are stressing price more than ever. The fact that they are all pushing the same value proposition means that their message might very well get lost, resulting in an inability to distinguish themselves from the competition.
Ted Marzilli, CEO of YouGov BrandIndex, commented that, “There is so much marketing and messaging out there to consumers, it becomes harder to break through and really come up with a compelling offering that drives people to stores….”
Rising Customer Dissatisfaction
Needless to say the aforementioned rise in customer complaints regarding the friendliness of McDonald’s staff and customer service are also threats, although McDonald’s new strategy for the counter might stem these issues.
Rise in the Minimum wage
There has been much talk lately in Washington over raising the minimum wage. The merits of doing so can be debated elsewhere–what is clear is that it would have a significant impact on companies like McDonald’s, Wendy’s, and Burger King.
President Obama has talked about raising the minimum wage to $9 an hour, while a congressman from Florida recently introduced a bill to raise it all the way to $10.50 an hour. Doing so would significantly increase expenses for McDonald’s, Wendy’s and Burger King.
Even though many of these companies employees make more than the minimum wage, most still make less than $10.50 an hour. In fact, the average food service worker makes $8.72 per hour.
If legislation changing the minimum wage goes through, these companies’ profit margins will get fried.
While McDonald’s stock might have performed well lately, there is a lot of risk going forward. Will the economy recover? Will McDonald’s value message get through to customers? Will people change their perception of McDonald’s? Will legislation increase expenses? It’s probably best to hold off until it all simmers down.
The article McDonald’s Is Getting Fried originally appeared on Fool.com and is written by Sean Sullivan.
Copyright © 1995 – 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.