Closer Look at PBF Energy Inc (PBF)’s Earnings

Page 1 of 2

Refiners have enjoyed one of the best years in a long time thanks to cheap domestic crude coming out of the middle of the country. We already know how the big guns faired — Valero Energy Corporation (NYSE:VLO) churned out operating income of $1.6 billionTesoro Corporation (NYSE:TSO) increased revenue to $8.2 billion — but last week we got to see how a smaller refining outfit fared in 2012. But size isn’t the only factor here. Keep in mind that two of the three facilities at PBF Energy Inc (NYSE:PBF) are located on the East Coast, a region that has been known in recent years as one of the hardest place in the U.S. to run a profitable refinery. On Friday, an analyst at Dahlman Rose reaffirmed the buy rating on PBF and slapped a $48 price target on this young stock. Let’s take a closer look at PBF’s earnings to see what all the fuss is about.

Valero Energy Corporation (NYSE:VLO)

General rundown
Right off the bat, CFO Matthew Lucey acknowledges that GAAP earnings will cover only the 14 days of post-IPO operations in 2012, so we got adjusted pro forma net income and EPS instead. With that, adjusted pro forma net income for the fourth quarter was $166 million, up from a loss of $112 million in 2011. Adjusted pro forma EPS came in at $1.70.

Operating income for the full year 2012 was $920 million, which demolished 2011’s $306 million. It should be noted that 2012 featured 12 months of operations for its three refineries, which was not the case in 2011. That year the Toledo refinery ran for only 10 months and the Delaware City refinery was only made fully operational by October.

Q4: Digging deeper
Management attributes the big boost in operating income to higher crack spreads and stronger crude differentials systemwide. That’s no surprise, remember, given the year that the refining industry has had. PBF Energy Inc (NYSE:PBF)’s margins are almost absurd: Systemwide refining margin was $13.04 per barrel, compared with $1.61 per barrel a year ago. Remember that for most of the year, the East Coast facilities were not getting the super-cheap oil that all the other refining outfits enjoyed.

On a micro-level, operating costs were down as energy and utility expenses fell, which helped PBF’s performance as well.

The overall throughput rates for the whole PBF system averaged 461,000 barrels per day: 147,000 bpd at the Mid-Continent (Toledo), and 314,000 bpd on the East Coast. Which brings us right back to those delightful margins. On the East Coast, realized margins were about $8.53 per barrel. In Toledo, that number was $22.71 per barrel. Here you see just how significant it is to be able to refine that cheap domestic crude, and why so many East Coast refineries have shut their doors in the past.

PBF’s East Coast margins should improve in 2013 as it takes advantage of its new crude unloading rail facility at the Delaware City refinery. Cheap crudes from Canada and North Dakota will hitch a ride on the train to Delaware and margins will improve provided the WCS and WTI discounts to Brent remain in place. PBF’s rail facilities give it a tremendous competitive advantage over other East Coast refiners that are forced to import their feedstock at a much higher price, again, as long as those differentials continue to exist.

A look ahead
The future looks bright at PBF, which is why the company is already ahead of the dividend-paying schedule it laid out in its IPO prospectus. A strong long-term outlook has allowed management top its planned $0.20 per share after the first quarter of 2013 and announce it will pay a fourth quarter dividend of $0.30 per share.

Page 1 of 2