4 Stock Success Stories From the 2009 “Sucker’s Rally”: Fifth Third Bancorp (FITB), Office Depot Inc (ODP), Krispy Kreme Doughnuts (KKD)

Page 1 of 2

The financial crisis ended — at least where the markets are concerned — four years ago. But some people couldn’t believe it was over. On the way back up, they warned that it was a garbage rally — a sucker’s game that would soon take adventurous investors to the poor house. Pundits and analysts pointed to dire financials and warned that soaring speculative selections might soon go the way of the dodo.

Plenty of stocks did go belly-up. But an elite few not only survived, but thrived, producing outsize gains that have made the Dow Jones Industrial Average‘s four-year double look like chump change. Make no mistake: These were some incredibly risky stocks to chase in the dark days of 2009, as you’ll soon see from a few eye-popping then-and-now financial comparisons. Did you listen to the doomsayers and sit on the sidelines, or did you jump in with both feet, not knowing when (if ever) you might touch bottom?

Fifth Third Bancorp (NASDAQ:FITB)Sucker’s-rally stocks that soared
The Dow bottomed out on March 9, 2009 after peaking in October of 2007, and it has since recovered to set fresh all-time highs. In the four years since that day, the index has gained 120%, which increases to 146% if its components’ dividends are added to the calculation. That’s not bad, but it can’t hold a candle to these “garbage stocks” that turned out to be diamonds in the rough. Each has returned at least 1,000% since the end of the financial-crisis crash, and some have recorded far greater gains than that:

Stock Total Loss from Peak to Trough (2007-2009) Market Cap at End of Crash Total Return Since End of Crash
Fifth Third Bancorp (NASDAQ:FITB) (96%) $802.6 million 1,150%
Office Depot Inc (NYSE:ODP) (97%) $162.2 million 600%
Krispy Kreme Doughnuts (NYSE:KKD) (74%) $74.3 million 1,240%
American International Group (NYSE:AIG) (99%) $788.7 million 575%

Source: YCharts.

What a wild ride. Let’s see how these companies have performed on a variety of metrics, both before and after the crash, to get a better understanding of why their stocks were so hated then — and why they’ve since proven the doubters wrong.

What happened to Fifth Third Bancorp (NASDAQ:FITB)?

Trailing-12-month earnings per share in 2009: -$3.94
Most recent TTM earnings per share: $1.66
Debt-to-cash ratio in 2009: 5
Most recent debt-to-cash ratio: 2.9
Total return from start of crash to today: -47%

On June 4, 2009, Ben Steverman of Bloomberg Businessweek cited market strategist Doug Peta:

The recent rally “is a necessary consequence after the real beating that equity markets have taken,” Peta says. He notes that Fifth Third Bancorp (NASDAQ:FITB) stock at one point hit $1 per share, a sure sign the bank’s survival was in doubt. But, after the Federal Reserve completed its so-called stress test of major banks, worries about Fifth Third eased and the stock jumped above $8. “Now, [investors believe] Fifth Third is going to survive — the government has said so,” Peta says. “It’s getting to trade on more traditional metrics.”

Fifth Third was in the same boat as many other regional banks coming out of the recession. However, its problems were magnified by the size of its bailout — $3.4 billion, which ultimately resulted in nearly $600 million in profit to the government by the time Fifth Third paid it off in early 2011. Nearly all of Fifth Third’s gain occurred by the end of 2010 and was largely built on a rebound in the bank’s price-to-book ratio. The bank hasn’t done much for shareholders since that time, and its most recent stress test results show that there’s still a way to go before Fifth Third Bancorp (NASDAQ:FITB) is back on a rock-solid foundation.

What happened to Office Depot Inc (NYSE:ODP)?

Trailing-12-month earnings per share in 2009: -$5.42
Most recent TTM earnings per share: -$0.39
Debt-to-cash ratio in 2009: 4.4
Most recent debt-to-cash ratio: 0.7
Total return from start of crash to today: -81%

Ben Steverman had this to say about Office Depot Inc (NYSE:ODP) in the same article:

The market’s rally was led by stocks like Office Depot, up 742%. … For years, Jeremy Grantham, co-founder of investment manager, was a bearish, pessimistic investor, but in early March he suggested stocks could be at their bottom. Like many investors, however, Grantham was surprised by how disproportionately the rally came from low-quality stocks, he said in a recent speech at the Morningstar Investment Conference. “It’s a junk rally,” Grantham said. Rutherford Investment Management president William Rutherford agrees, calling the past three months a “dash to trash.” Rutherford’s funds had stuck with high-quality stocks that he was sure would make it through the financial crisis and recession. As a result, he says, “We missed out on a lot of [the] increase.”

Office Depot Inc (NYSE:ODP) posted all of its gains by the middle of 2010 — despite a 2012 surge, it remains 25% below its value at the start of 2011. The second-string office supply retailer has had difficulties maintaining profitability, and free cash flow has been in decline since 2009 as well. On the plus side, Office Depot’s cash pile is up significantly, and its debt recently dropped by a quarter. A merger agreement with OfficeMax Inc (NYSE:OMX) sent shares spiking last month, but investors remain unsure as to how they should approach this new tie-up.

What happened to Krispy Kreme Doughnuts (NYSE:KKD)?

Trailing-12-month earnings per share in 2009: -$0.06
Most recent TTM earnings per share: $2.23
Debt-to-cash ratio in 2009: 2.1
Most recent debt-to-cash ratio: 0.5
Total return from start of crash to today: 248%

On April 20, 2009, Josh Brown of the Reformed Broker blog wrote:

Page 1 of 2
Comments
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy
Insider Monkey Small Cap Strategy

Insider Monkey beat the market by 52 percentage points in 24 months. Our beta is only 1.2 (don't click this link if beating the market isn't important to you).

Lists

The 10 Largest Pharmaceutical Companies In the World

The 10 Most Expensive Android Apps

The 9 Most Expensive Designer Bags in the World

The 7 Most Expensive Real Estate in the World

The 10 Most Expensive eBay Items Ever Sold

The 10 Most Expensive iPhone Apps

The 9 Most Expensive Designer Shoes in the World

The 10 Most Expensive Cigarette Brands

The 10 Most Expensive Law Schools in the US

The 10 Best Wall Street Movies

The 10 Most Expensive Golf Clubs Ever Sold

The 10 Most Expensive Golf Memberships

The 10 Best Disney Characters Ever Created

The 8 Best Foods for Gaining Weight

The 10 Most Expensive Colleges in the World

The 7 Most Memorable Ad Campaigns of All Time

The 7 Most Expensive High Schools in the World

The 10 Electric Vehicles with the Longest Range

The 10 Cities with the Worst Drivers in the World

The 10 Most Expensive Dresses Ever Created

10 Islands to Visit Before You Die

10 Famous Celebrities Who Needed Rehab

The 15 Countries with the Largest Oil Reserves

The 10 Most Overused Excuses in the World

The 5 Best iOS Apps You Can’t Get on Android

5 Companies Damaged By Social Media Blunders

The 10 Most Legendary Blues Songs

The 10 Most Lawless Places in the World

4 Reasons China is a Threat to the US

The 17 Most Sugary Drinks in the World

The 10 Most Ruthless Rulers in History

The 10 Greatest Generals in History

Top 8 Travel Destinations for 2015

The 10 Safest Dog Breeds for Children

The 10 Most Stolen Vehicles in the US

The 7 Most Expensive Celebrity Weddings

The 10 Best LoL Teams in the World

Top 10 Worst Marketing Campaigns Ever Produced

Top 5 Diets that Help You Lose Weight

The 10 Best Ways to Stay Awake

7 Artists That Switched Musical Genres

The 10 Most Expensive Cities to Live in New Jersey

The 10 Best High Schools in New York

The 10 Countries With the Least Gender Inequality

The 6 Biggest Musician-Manager Feuds

The 10 Countries with the Cheapest Gas Prices

The 7 Most Theatrical Bands of All Time

The 8 Worst Band Breakups of All Time

The 10 Most Important South American Leaders

The 7 Most Successful Casting Show Winners

Subscribe

Enter your email:

Delivered by FeedBurner

X

Thanks! An email with instructions is sent to !

Your email already exists in our database. Click here to go to your subscriptions

Insider Monkey returned 47.6% in its first year! Wondering How?

Download a complete edition of our newsletter for free!